A CEO Woman Was Refused Service at a Beverly Hills Jewelry Store — Then One Quiet Name Made the Entire Showroom Freeze

Chapter 25

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Ivy then showed them the pattern in her files. Of the twenty-three pieces she had appraised for the store over four years, fourteen had been altered in the store's customer copies. In every case the alteration raised the price. In no case did it lower it. In twelve cases a provenance story had been added or expanded. In nine cases a disclosure about a repair, a replacement stone, or a treatment had been removed. Ivy had kept a log, because she was the kind of person who kept logs, and the log listed each piece, the date of her original, the date she had seen the altered copy, and the difference in price. Paula photographed each page of the log with Ivy's permission, and Ivy signed and dated a short statement Paula had drafted on the spot, stating that the reports in the thin folder were her originals, that the store's copies differed from them, and that she had not authorized the changes.

Before they left, Ivy took Helen's hand for a moment. She was thirty-one, and she looked younger when she was not talking about appraisals, and she said she had been afraid that coming forward would end her practice in Naples, because Baldwin and Rowe was well known and she was not. Helen told her, truthfully, that she did not know what would happen to the store, but that a report kept in a drawer helped no one, and that a report shown to the right people, with its original beside the altered copy, was very hard to argue with. Paula added, in her practical way, that Ivy would not be asked to do anything alone, that anything filed would be filed by Paula on Helen's behalf, and that Ivy's role was simply to tell the truth about her own work. Ivy nodded, and when Helen and Paula stepped back out into the bright street, the thin folder was in Paula's bag, and the thick folder stayed with Ivy, locked in her safe, with a copy of her signed statement tucked inside it.

Harriet Vane lived in a small house with a garden she tended herself, on a street where the houses were close enough that neighbors knew when someone's car had not moved for a day. She was seventy-two, with white hair cut short and hands that were steady when she poured tea, and she had kept, in a box on top of her wardrobe, every letter the store had ever sent her. When Helen and Paula arrived in the afternoon, she brought the box down without being asked, set it on the kitchen table, and lifted out a consignment contract dated four years earlier, printed on the store's letterhead and signed by both Harriet and a representative of Baldwin and Rowe.

The contract was for her mother's brooch, a gold piece set with small diamonds and a single ruby, which Harriet's mother had worn for fifty years and which Harriet had decided to sell after her mother died, because she did not wear brooches and because she wanted the money to help pay for repairs to the house. The contract stated that the store would display the brooch, that it would be sold at a price agreed with Harriet, and that Harriet would receive eighty percent of the sale price within thirty days of the sale, with the store retaining twenty percent as commission. Harriet had initialed each page. The store's representative had signed the last page in a hand Harriet still recognized.

"It sold," Harriet said, in a voice that was matter-of-fact because she had told the story to herself so many times that the surprise had worn out of it. "I know it sold because I went into the store one day, six months after I left it there, and it was not in the case, and the young woman behind the counter told me it had been sold the previous month to a customer from out of state. When I asked when I would be paid, she went to the back and came back with the manager, and the manager told me there had been a delay with the buyer's payment, and that I should be patient."

Patience, Harriet explained, had lasted another year. She had written four letters, each one polite, each one asking for the same thing: the date of sale, the sale price, and the payment owed to her under the contract. The store had answered two of them. The first answer said the sale was still being finalized. The second said the brooch had in fact been sold for less than expected, that after commission and cleaning and a charge for display, there was very little left, and that a small payment would follow. No payment followed. The third and fourth letters were not answered at all. Harriet produced them, too, with the store's two replies, and Paula read each one and laid them in order on the table, earliest first, like a timeline that needed no explanation.

News in the same category

A CEO Woman Was Refused Service at a Beverly Hills Jewelry Store — Then One Quiet Name Made the Entire Showroom Freeze

45 Part