A CEO Woman Was Refused Service at a Beverly Hills Jewelry Store — Then One Quiet Name Made the Entire Showroom Freeze

Chapter 29

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Before they parted, Sofia copied the relevant pages of her notebook for Paula, with dates but without any customer names she did not know, and signed a short statement that the copies were true copies of notes she had made at the time, in her own hand. She put her store pin back on her collar, straightened her blouse, and walked back toward Baldwin and Rowe for the second half of her shift, looking, Helen thought, both smaller and steadier than she had when she sat down. Helen watched her go and thought about how much of the store's story depended on young people like Sofia deciding that politeness did not require silence, and how much courage it took to write a question mark in the margin of a notebook and then, months later, to show that notebook to strangers in a café.

The pattern widened the way a tide widens, not all at once but with each new conversation adding a little more ground to what Helen and Paula already knew. Paula began by writing, carefully and without any suggestion of what the answer should be, to every consignor whose name appeared in the papers Harriet had kept and in the margins of Ivy's log, and to others whose names Sofia had remembered from the counter, even when Sofia had only a first name and a description of a piece. Some people did not reply. Some replied to say they had been paid in full and had no complaint, and Paula thanked them and set their letters aside, because a fair file had to include the people who had been treated well as well as those who had not. Others replied with stories that rhymed with Harriet's so closely that Helen, reading them at Paula's table in the evenings, began to feel a kind of tired recognition, as if she were hearing the same polite delay played in different keys.

Marian Doyle, a retired teacher, had consigned her aunt's pearl and diamond pendant, had been told it sold for eleven thousand dollars, and had received four thousand after what the store called adjustments, although her contract, which she still had, promised eighty percent and listed no such adjustments. Willa Forsyth had consigned a pair of emerald earrings and had waited fourteen months for a payment that arrived, at last, for less than half the agreed share, with no explanation of the sale price and no invitation to see the record of the sale. A man named Leonard Bixby, who had consigned his late wife's ring, had been told the ring had not sold at all, and had asked for it back, only to be told it was in a vault and would take weeks to retrieve; when he pressed, he was told it had in fact sold the previous year, and a small check followed, for an amount that did not match any price he had ever discussed. Corinne Ashworth had consigned a bracelet and had never been told, in writing, whether it had sold, although she had seen a piece very like it in the store's window months later, at a price far above what she had been told it was worth.

Paula kept a table, and the table grew. For each consignor she recorded the piece, the contract share, the price the store had reported, the amount actually paid, and the difference. She did not fill in a line until she had a document for it: a contract, a letter, a check stub, a photograph of a price card. Where she had only a memory, she marked the line as unconfirmed and set it aside. Even with that discipline, the confirmed lines added up with a steadiness that left little room for argument. By the end of the second week, Paula had eleven consignors whose cases were documented: eleven people, over four years, who had been unpaid or underpaid, some by a few thousand dollars, some, like Harriet, by the whole amount. The total of what they were owed, measured against their contracts and the sale prices the store itself had recorded, came to roughly six hundred and twenty thousand dollars. Paula wrote the figure in pencil at the bottom of the table, circled it, and then wrote beside it, in smaller letters, the word approximate, because she wanted Helen to understand that it was a floor, not a ceiling: it counted only what could be proved from papers already in hand, and it did not count the consignors who had not replied, or the sales for which no record had yet been found.

News in the same category

A CEO Woman Was Refused Service at a Beverly Hills Jewelry Store — Then One Quiet Name Made the Entire Showroom Freeze

45 Part