A CEO Woman Was Refused Service at a Beverly Hills Jewelry Store — Then One Quiet Name Made the Entire Showroom Freeze

Chapter 37

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The fourth folder held Sofia Reyes's notes. Sofia was twenty-four, and she had started at Baldwin & Rowe the previous autumn, and she had kept a small notebook in which she wrote down what she saw on the floor, not because she had planned to be a witness but because she was new and careful and wanted to remember how things were done. The notebook recorded dates on which plain-dressed customers were steered to the low-priced cases, dates on which customers who asked about the heritage pieces were asked about their budgets before they were shown anything, and dates on which consignors who called about payouts were told the store would look into it and then were not called back. Sofia had not written any of it in anger. She had written it the way a person writes down a recipe she wants to get right, and that plainness made it difficult to dismiss. Paula had met Sofia twice, both times with Helen present, because Sofia had asked for Helen to be there, and Paula had understood that request without needing it explained: Sofia had almost intervened for Helen on Helen's first visit, had been waved off by Bridget Calloway, and had carried that moment with her since, and having Helen in the room made the notes feel less like a report about a stranger and more like an account of something she had watched happen to a person she knew.

Sofia was nervous about the hearing, and she did not hide it. "I still work there," she said at the second meeting, her hands flat on the table as if to keep them still. "I need this job. I also need to be able to look at what I wrote and know I told the truth about it. I am not trying to be brave. I am trying to be accurate."

"You are being both," Helen said, and Sofia had looked down at her hands and then up again, and Paula had made a note to herself that Helen's steadiness was doing more for this case than any argument Paula could make, because witnesses who felt steadied told the truth more plainly than witnesses who felt coached.

The fifth folder, the one Paula handled last and most carefully, held the second ledger. It had come to Paula through a chain she would describe to the panel only in general terms, because the person who had provided it still worked in the trade and did not want to be named in a public room, and Paula respected that, and the panel would have to weigh the ledger on its own contents rather than on its source. The ledger was a plain book, smaller than Gus's, with entries in a different hand, recording real payouts to consignors alongside the amounts the store had recorded in its official books. The gap between the two columns, added up over four years and eleven consignors besides Harriet, came to roughly six hundred and twenty thousand dollars. Paula had had an accountant go through it twice, and the accountant had produced a summary that was two pages long and that used no adjectives at all, which Paula considered its greatest strength.

"This is the folder that changes the size of the case," Paula said. "One consignor unpaid is a dispute. Eleven consignors, over four years, with a second set of books, is a pattern. The association will understand that. The attorney general's office will understand it even better. Our job is to present it without overstating it. We say what the ledger shows, we say what the accountant verified, and we let the numbers sit there."

Helen asked about Bridget Calloway and Adam Roth, and Paula answered directly, as she always did. Bridget had hired a lawyer, a man from Tampa who specialized in professional licensing matters, and he had filed a response denying that any provenance had been fabricated and characterizing the payout discrepancies as bookkeeping errors and timing differences. Adam Roth had filed a shorter response, denying that he had altered any payout, and Paula said his response was shorter because there was less to say that would help him, given that his initials appeared on several of the altered payout sheets. Neither of them had contacted Helen directly since the quiet-fix meeting, and Paula said that was just as well, because anything they said now would be said in a room with a record being kept.

The quiet-fix meeting had taken place three weeks earlier, in Paula's office, at Bridget's request. Bridget had come alone, without her lawyer, which Paula had noted but not commented on, and she had offered Helen the necklace at what she called a private discount, a price well below the one-hundred-and-forty-eight-thousand-dollar asking price but still above the true appraised value, on the condition that Helen sign a nondisclosure agreement covering the necklace, the provenance, and the store's consignment practices. Helen had listened to the whole offer without interrupting, and then she had said no, in the same even tone she used for everything, and she had said it was not because she wanted more money or a better price, but because a private discount would have settled her own matter and left the other consignors exactly where they were. Bridget had left without arguing, and Paula had written a memorandum of the meeting the same afternoon, while the words were still exact in her mind, and that memorandum was now in the first folder, behind Paula's cover letter, where the panel would see it early.

News in the same category

A CEO Woman Was Refused Service at a Beverly Hills Jewelry Store — Then One Quiet Name Made the Entire Showroom Freeze

45 Part