Helen asked Harriet what the brooch had been listed at. Harriet opened a second envelope and took out a photograph she had taken of the brooch in the store's case on the day she consigned it, with the price card just visible beside it. The card read twenty-four thousand dollars. Eighty percent of that, Paula calculated aloud, would have been nineteen thousand two hundred dollars, even before any discussion of whether the final sale price had been higher or lower. Harriet had received nothing. Not a partial payment, not a check for a lesser amount, not an offer to return the piece. Nothing, for a brooch that had belonged to her mother and that the store had sold and kept the money for.
"I stopped going in," Harriet said. "I felt foolish, standing at that counter asking for my own money. And I thought, perhaps, that I had misunderstood the contract, that there was a clause I had missed. I read it again last winter, all the way through, and there is no clause that says they may keep the whole price. There is no clause that says they may wait four years."
Paula asked, gently, whether Harriet had kept any other records: a receipt for the consignment, a copy of the store's inventory tag, anything with a number on it. Harriet went to the box again and found the inventory tag, still attached to a piece of card, with the brooch's description and a stock number written in ink. She also found a note she had made herself on the day of consignment, in a small notebook, recording the name of the salesperson who had taken the brooch in and the price they had discussed. That salesperson was Adam Roth. Harriet remembered him because he had been kind on that first day, complimenting the brooch and telling her it would find a good home. She had not seen him on her later visits. On those visits she had been met by the manager.
Helen listened, and thought about how different Harriet's story was from her own and how similar the shape of it was. Helen had been steered away from a case. Harriet had been steered away from her own money, politely, over months, until politeness itself became the mechanism. No one had shouted at Harriet. No one had needed to. A delay, a second explanation, an unanswered letter: each step was small enough to seem like an error, and together they added up to a sale with no payout at all.
Paula explained, without promising an outcome, what she and Helen were doing: gathering original documents from people who had consigned pieces to the store, comparing what the store had promised with what it had paid, and preparing to put that comparison before the jewelers' association and the state consumer authorities. She asked Harriet whether she would be willing to let Paula copy the contract, the letters, the inventory tag, and her notebook page, and whether she would be willing to sign a statement describing what had happened in her own words. Harriet said yes at once, and then, with a practicality that Helen admired, asked whether she should also write down the dates she had visited the store, as best she could remember them, because she had not written those down at the time and did not want to guess.
Paula said that was exactly right: write only what she was sure of, and mark anything uncertain as uncertain. Harriet sat at the table with a pen and wrote for twenty minutes while Helen and Paula waited, and when she finished she read the statement aloud, corrected one date, and signed it. Paula made copies on a small portable scanner she carried in her bag, returned the originals to Harriet, and put the copies in her folder beside Ivy's reports. As they left, Harriet walked them to the gate and said she had not expected anyone to come and ask, and that for a long time she had thought the brooch was simply gone, like her mother, and that there was nothing to be done about either loss. Helen took her hand and said that the brooch might be gone, but the contract was not, and that a contract was a kind of record that did not fade the way memory did. On the drive back, Paula said very little, but Helen could see her making notes at a red light, adding Harriet's name to a list that was beginning, page by page, to look less like a list of complaints and more like a pattern.