She slept well that night, which surprised her a little, and woke early, and dressed carefully, not in anything new, but in a dress she had worn before and felt steady in, a deep blue linen dress with no logos and no ornament, and she packed the tote bag with the letters and the photograph, although Paula had told her she would not need them in the room, and she went downstairs to find that the morning was clear and warm, with the kind of light that made Naples look like a postcard and also like a real place, which it was, both at once. Paula picked her up at eight, and they drove to Tampa in Paula's car, talking about the wedding on the way, because Paula had decided, wisely, that a morning spent only on a hearing would make the hearing feel larger than it was, and Helen was grateful for the conversation about flowers and music and the small, good problem of where to seat two cousins who did not speak to each other.
The conference room in Tampa was exactly as Paula had described it: plain carpet, a long table, windows that did not open, and a row of chairs along the wall for observers. The panel sat at the head of the table, three people in business clothes, with name cards in front of them and a pitcher of water in the middle that nobody touched for the first hour. The panel chair was a woman in her sixties with silver hair cut short and a manner that suggested she had run many such rooms and had no patience for speeches. Beside her sat a man who had owned a jewelry store in another part of the state for thirty years and who listened with his hands folded, and beside him sat a younger woman who took notes continuously, in a notebook rather than on a laptop, which Helen noticed and liked, because it meant the notes would be in the woman's own hand. Paula sat at the table with Helen beside her, and across from them sat Bridget Calloway with her lawyer, and Adam Roth with a lawyer of his own, a younger man who kept his papers in a neat stack and rarely looked up from them. Sofia sat in the row of chairs along the wall, between Gus and Ivy, and Harriet sat at the end of that row, closest to the door, with her hands folded in her lap and a small handbag at her feet.
The chair opened the hearing by reading the complaint aloud, in a clear voice, without emphasis, and the complaint was Paula's document, which meant it was precise and unadorned, and hearing it read back made Helen feel, for the first time, that the whole matter had a shape that other people could see. The complaint alleged that Baldwin & Rowe had sold pieces in its heritage line with fabricated provenances, had altered independent appraisal reports to support inflated prices, and had failed to pay or had underpaid consignors over a period of four years. It named the necklace only as one example, and it named Harriet Vane only as one consignor, and it asked the association to suspend the heritage line, to order restitution to all affected consignors, and to take appropriate disciplinary action against the individuals responsible. The chair read it to the end, set the paper down, and said, "We will hear the evidence in the order it is presented. We will ask questions. We ask everyone to speak plainly and to answer the question that was asked."
Paula began with Gus, because Paula believed, correctly, that a room should first hear from a man who had kept a book for fifty years. Gus walked to the table slowly, sat down, opened his log to the marked page, and read the entry aloud, exactly as he had practiced, slowly, without looking up until he had finished. Then Paula asked him to show the panel the mark, and Gus produced the necklace, which had been brought to the hearing in a locked case by Paula herself, and he turned it over in his hands with the familiarity of a man handling his own work, and he pointed to the inside of the hinge, where the tiny mark sat, and he held it up so the panel could see it, and the man who had owned a store for thirty years leaned forward and looked, and nodded, once, as if he had seen such a mark before and knew what it meant. Paula asked Gus when he had made the repair, and Gus said the date, and Paula asked him for whom, and Gus said the name, Eleanor Marsh, and Paula asked him whether the necklace in his hands was the necklace he had repaired, and Gus said yes, it was, that he knew his own work, and that the clasp he had repaired was the clasp he was holding.
Bridget's lawyer asked Gus whether he could be certain, after so many years, that this was the same piece, and Gus said he could, because the repair was his, and the mark was his, and the entry was his, written on the day, and he did not raise his voice or argue, and the lawyer asked no further questions, which Helen took as a sign that there were no further questions worth asking. The chair thanked Gus, and Gus closed his log, put it back in its cloth bag, and returned to his chair along the wall, and Helen watched him go with a feeling she could not quite name, something between gratitude and protectiveness, as if Gus had lent the room something valuable and she wanted to make sure he got it back.