Nicole told it then, in the order it had happened to her, which is the only order the wretched ever have. Her father had called her on a Friday night, three weeks before, from his car, and said there had been an emergency with a former employee, a woman scorned, mentally unwell, who was making threats and accusations, and that the woman's little girl needed to be kept safe and quiet for a few days, a very few days, while lawyers resolved it, somewhere no one would look and no one would be hurt. He had said the child's mother had agreed, in her distress, that the girl should be somewhere familiar and warm. He had said the room in Nicole's own house, behind Emma's closet, a room Nicole had known about since she was a girl visiting the house's previous owners with her father on a business call she no longer remembered the purpose of, and which she had never once mentioned to her husband in five years of living inside its walls, a fact she placed in the record herself, before Rourke could.
"He said a few days," Nicole said. "I believed the few days because the alternative was believing the rest. I fed her because the alternative was not feeding her, and I would like the record to show that I understand what I just said. I fed her through the panel, after dark, when Simon was asleep or out. I told Emma the noises were the wind because Emma was four and asked at breakfast. I told myself the father of my child was a criminal, or a savior, on alternate days, and on both kinds of days I carried the tray upstairs. A few days became three weeks the way six years became six years. It was the same arithmetic. It was always the same arithmetic. I was the arithmetic."
Across town, in the same hours, Marj Wexler was giving her own statement to a second detective, at her kitchen table, with Emma asleep in the next room under a quilt Marj had made the winter Simon was born. She remembered Erin's call. She remembered it exactly, she said, because she had been shelling peas and because a woman does not forget answering her own telephone and hearing her daughter-in-law take a call on the extension in a voice too bright for the hour, and because she had found, afterward, a note in her own hand on the pad by the phone, in the shorthand of a woman who had taken messages in a school office for thirty years: E., it said. 9th. No message. She had kept the pad. She had the pad still, in the drawer under the phone, and she gave it to the detective in a sandwich bag, and said, "I did not know what it was. I knew it was kept. In this family we are starting, late, to distinguish between those two things."
Curtis Hartigan was arrested on the Wednesday, at his lake house, in the middle of a telephone call he was conducting with the air of a man closing a difficult quarter.
The lake house was on a reservoir forty minutes north, a place of dock and decking and a screened porch where the Hartigan family had posed for photographs in better decades, and Curtis had gone to it on the Friday night his daughter called him, in tears, to say the words the girl is out of the wall, and he had stayed there five days with his phone and his liquor and a lake view, composing accounts. Rourke, who coordinated the arrest with the county sheriff and two state investigators, described it afterward to Simon in the flat tone he used for completed paperwork: the subject was taken on the porch, without incident, in carpet slippers, holding a cordless phone handset, which he attempted, in the first seconds, to use as an introduction, offering to call his attorney for the officers, as if the officers were a delivery that had arrived at the wrong house.
He asked, in the car, whether his daughter was all right. He asked it twice, an hour apart, with the same words, and the deputy who drove him wrote both askings in his notes, because the deputy had children and had developed, over twenty years, a private system for weighing such things: a man who asks the same question twice has not heard any answer he can use.
The charges, when they were filed on the Thursday, were read aloud in a courtroom Simon did not attend, at Rourke's advice and his own inclination, and he read them instead in the charging document the detective left with him, on his mother's porch, in the afternoon, with Emma's library books in a pile beside his chair. Kidnapping. Conspiracy to commit kidnapping. Witness tampering. Medicaid fraud, in counts that ran down the page like the rows of the ledgers that had made them. Unlawful confinement. He read the document twice and then he read the line about the pickup authorization, forged, a mother's signature copied from a personnel file, and he understood that there was a species of paper he had never kept in his deed box, the paper other people made out of yours when you were not watching, and that the world ran on both kinds.