I found a little girl living behind my daughter's closet wall

Chapter 8

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The first letter was dated from Indianapolis, in the spring of the year Emma would have been conceived in another life. Erin wrote that she was pregnant. She wrote that she had not planned to tell him this way. She wrote that she was not asking for anything he would read as an asking; she was telling him because he was the kind of man who kept his paper in order and a child was paper he was entitled to. She wrote that she would be at her sister's in Ohio until the birth and that the number at the bottom still worked, and then she wrote the number at the bottom, in her printed hand, digit by digit, like a woman setting down something heavy with both hands.

The second letter was shorter. A daughter, it said. Born in November, in Columbus, seven pounds, all her fingers, a small dark mark beneath her left ear that the nurses had called a beauty spot. Her name is Margot, the letter said. She looks at the world like it owes her an explanation. I thought you should have that in writing too.

Simon sat at his dining table under the good light with the blueprints of his house weighted by salt cellars, and he read the two letters twice, and then he put them back in their envelopes with the care of a man handling the only copies of a thing, and he slid them across the table to the detective.

"I never saw these," he said. "I want that in your record. I never saw these letters."

"It is in the record," Rourke said. "It was in the record when you signed the consent, Mr. Wexler, whether you know it or not. A man who has seen those letters does not consent to opening the box they are hidden in." He put the envelopes in evidence bags with the delicacy of a pharmacist. "Now. I am going to ask you some questions, and the first one is about your telephone."

Simon gave him the telephone. Rourke found Erin Sutter in the contacts in under a minute, under S, with a small photograph Simon had forgotten the phone had kept, and beside her name a word Simon had to read twice: Blocked. The block, the phone reported, in its bloodless way, had been set on a Saturday in the spring, six years before, on the weekend Nicole had sat at this same table with both their phones and done what she called a spam purge, laughing, asking him whether he really needed four hundred contacts from a school he no longer worked at, while Emma, not yet born, was still a rumor of nausea and joy in the next room of their lives.

"I did not block her," Simon said.

"No," Rourke said. "I do not think you did."

In the kitchen doorway Nicole had begun, very quietly, to cry, standing up, without covering her face, the way a person cries at weather. She did not deny the letters. She would deny, for another day, almost everything else, in the order people deny things, from the largest to the smallest, but she stood in the doorway of her own kitchen with her arms folded inside another woman's cardigan and she did not deny that the letters in the evidence bags had come to this house addressed to her husband, and been opened, and been kept.

"I was afraid," she said, to no one in particular, to the room, to the architecture. "That is not an excuse. I know it is not an excuse. I am telling you the order of it. I was afraid first."

Erin Sutter had filed the complaint three days before they took her daughter, and she had filed it the way she did everything that mattered, in writing, with copies.

She had been Hartigan Medical Supply's billing manager for four years, in the years after Margot was born, working remotely from Indianapolis for the company whose owner had once been, in the geography of Simon's life, a name at a fundraiser. She had taken the job without knowing whose it was. Bookkeeping work came through agencies and the name Hartigan had meant nothing to her until the day she met the owner at a compliance seminar in a hotel ballroom and heard him called to the stage, and understood, with the floor going soft under her, that her daughter's grandfather, in every way but law and knowledge, owned the building she had been keeping books in for a year.

News in the same category

I found a little girl living behind my daughter's closet wall

45 Part