I found a little girl living behind my daughter's closet wall

Chapter 18

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The interim order came down the following week, in a courtroom with a flag and a radiator that knocked, once, cleanly, in a way no one in the room mistook for anything but a radiator. Emma would live with Simon. Nicole would have contact twice a week, supervised, at a center with a sign-in book and a waiting room full of other families' worst seasons, and the judge, a woman with reading glasses and a voice like a closing door, read the terms aloud and then looked over the glasses at Simon and said, "The court notes the child's sister is resident in your mother's home at present and will be resident in yours. The court further notes that the child Emma's account of events, given at four years old, has been corroborated in every particular that could be checked. Somebody in this family keeps excellent records. The court hopes it continues."

The DNA result arrived in an envelope of its own, from the court, in the same week: probability of paternity stated in the stately decimals of the laboratory, a number so close to certainty that the difference was a rounding of the world's patience. Simon read it standing in Marj's driveway, where the mail came, and then he sat down in the driver's seat of his car with the door open and read it again, because it was the first document in six years that told him a thing about his own life before his wife's filing system did, and because Margot Sutter, aged six, who had his mark beneath her ear and his mother's chin and Erin's printed-hand way of finishing a sentence, was, as of that envelope, his daughter in the only tense the law recognizes, which is also, he was learning, the tense that pays for school shoes and signs the forms.

He entered it in the house notebook, under the date, beneath the entry for the burst pipe at the school and the entry for the panel: Daughter confirmed. Both of them. All the paperwork in the world, and it had taken a slice of bread through a gap in a wall to get the family its correct membership.

At Margot's school in Indianapolis, in the same week, a detective collected the last of the pickup file, and the program director Carla, at Erin's request and with the court's blessing, struck the forged authorization from the record and entered a new page in the pickup book, which Erin signed in her printed hand, slowly, like a woman laying a cornerstone. Authorized to collect Margot Sutter: Erin Sutter, mother. Simon Wexler, father. Two names. The page had room for six, and Erin, who had filled in other people's forms all her working life, left the other four lines empty and ruled a line beneath the second name, and said, "That is the complete list. It totals correctly. Let it stand."

Erin gave her evidence to the state fraud unit on a Tuesday, in a conference room in a state building in Indianapolis, and she dressed for it the way she had dressed for audits in her billing years: a plain suit, her hair back, a folder that closed properly. Okafor was there, and a state investigator named Brandt with a legal pad, and a court reporter, and a carafe of water that Erin noted, without comment, was placed within her reach, full, before anyone sat down.

She was there for four hours. She took the investigators through the pattern the way she had found it, one wrong line at a time: the immaculate logs, the rotating signatures, the serial numbers that resolved to no purchase order in any year. She identified the batches she had processed herself, in her billing years, initialing the ones that were hers with a small tick in the margin, because she had told Okafor on the phone that she would not have it said, later, that Erin Sutter's evidence began conveniently after Erin Sutter's employment. "If I billed a ghost," she said, "I want it in the record that I have said so, in this room, first. My initials are on nine of these. I did not know what they were. That is my shame and it is also my evidence, because a woman planning a fraud does not usually begin by reporting herself in a conference room."

"You are the most dangerous witness I have deposed this year," Brandt said at the end, not unkindly, looking at the four hours of indexed exhibits, "and I include two accountants and a man who kept his bribes in a spreadsheet with a password."

"The password was probably his dog," Erin said. "Men like that always use the dog."

News in the same category

I found a little girl living behind my daughter's closet wall

45 Part