She had kept the job. She told her sister Dawn that she had kept it for the insurance, and the money, and because Margot's father did not know Margot existed and a woman with a child does not walk away from a salary over a coincidence. All of that was true. Underneath it, in the part of her accounts she did not show Dawn, was another truth: the job put her, a few times a year, in Fort Wayne, in the same weather as Simon Wexler, and once, at a distance of forty yards across a school parking lot, she had seen him help a crossing guard fold a sign, and laugh at something the woman said, and she had sat in her car with her hands on the wheel until her breathing behaved.
The billing pattern found her the way billing patterns do, one wrong line at a time. A wheelchair delivered to a nursing facility in Auburn, billed, paid, and then billed again in the next cycle under a new serial number she could not trace to any purchase order. She was a billing manager. Tracing was the work. She pulled the delivery logs, and the logs were clean, and that was the wrongness: in six years of medical supply, Erin had never seen a delivery log with no errors in it, no smudged signatures, no missed Tuesdays. The Hartigan logs for the facility contracts were immaculate, and immaculate, in her profession, was what a lie looked like when it had been to finishing school.
She worked it at night for five weeks, at her kitchen table in Indianapolis, with Margot asleep in the next room and the copies spreading in a grid under a desk lamp: invoices, purchase orders, the state payment portal's remittance records, which she could access because no one had ever imagined the billing manager would audit her own desk. Two hundred and fourteen units, in the end, billed to Medicaid and never delivered at all, wheelchairs and beds and lift chairs that existed only in the portal, with delivery receipts signed in three hands that rotated too evenly to be three people. Four hundred and some thousand dollars. She wrote it up in a memo in her printed hand, with the copies clipped behind it in order, and she made two sets, and she gave one set to her sister Dawn in a grocery bag at a rest stop on I-70, and said, "If anything is ever strange, this is the strange thing," and Dawn, who was the elder and the calmer, put the bag in her hall closet and said, "Nothing will be strange, Erin," with the confidence of a woman who has never worked in billing.
The complaint went to the state Medicaid fraud hotline on a Tuesday. It was acknowledged on the Thursday, in a letter Erin read four times at her mailbox: a case number, a name of a unit, a sentence in bureaucratic oak that said the complaint had been received and logged and could not be withdrawn by the complainant. She put the letter in her purse. She told Dawn the case number over the phone, and her own address, and Margot's school, in the new habit she had developed without deciding to: everything important, said aloud, to a second person, in a second place.
On the Friday, Margot did not come out of the after-school program with the other children.
The program director, a young woman named Carla who cried before Erin did, produced the pickup log with hands that shook: Margot Sutter, released at 4:12 p.m., to an authorized pickup, signature on file. The authorization was a form Erin had never seen, bearing her own signature in a copy so good it made her dizzy, listing, in the box for additional authorized persons, a name Erin had typed a thousand times on invoices: Curtis Hartigan, grandfather, with a phone number that rang, when the Indianapolis detective rang it in Erin's hearing, to a disconnected line. The program's camera, mounted over the door to catch the weather and the occasional custody dispute, had caught a silver sedan and a man in a cap, and the still, printed out grainy on the detective's paper, showed a big man with his head turned away and a ring on the hand on the door frame.
Erin said, "That is Curtis Hartigan. He owns the company I filed the complaint against. The complaint is three days old. He has taken my daughter to make me withdraw it, and it cannot be withdrawn, and he does not know that, and you need to find her before he finds it out."