The words hung in the air. Twin sister. I had known it, in a way, since the moment Elena had asked me where her daughter was, since the moment she had told me about the birth night, since the moment I had understood that the second baby had not died at all. But hearing Elena say it out loud, in that room, to Rebecca's face, was different. It made it real in a way that nothing else had.
Ava's twin sister. My daughter. The baby I had been told was dead before I had ever seen her face. The baby whose death certificate my father had paid a doctor to sign. The baby who had been alive all this time, six years old now, living in a house I did not know, calling another woman mother, believing her own mother was dead and her own father did not want her.
I thought about Ava, at home in her room, or perhaps standing outside the library door, listening. I thought about the two of them, born together, separated before they had even had a chance to know each other existed. I thought about the trust, and the conditions, and the way my father had planned it all so that the two girls would never meet, so that the two identities would never be reunited, so that the trust could never be challenged. And I thought about what it meant that they were about to meet, right here, in this house, in this room, because of a little girl in a pink dress who had run into a proposal party and screamed that her mother was under the pool.
"Where is she?" I asked. My voice sounded rough, even to me. "Where is Sophie now? Where have you been keeping her?"
Rebecca looked at me, and she looked at Elena, and she looked at Graham, and for a moment, I thought she was going to lie again. I thought she was going to say that Sophie was away, or that Sophie was safe, or that Sophie did not want to see us. But then her shoulders dropped, just a little, and the fight went out of her all at once, like air going out of a balloon, and she looked smaller than I had ever seen her look, and older, and very tired.
"She is here," Rebecca said. "She is in the house. Daniel brought her here two days ago. She has been upstairs, in the guest room, waiting. She does not know what is happening. She does not know who you are. She thinks I am her mother, and she thinks her mother is dead, and she thinks her father did not want her, and I have not told her otherwise, because I did not know what else to do."
Elena made a sound then, a small, broken sound, and she turned toward the door, and I caught her arm, and I held her back, because I knew what she was going to do, and I knew we had to be careful, and I knew that a frightened six-year-old girl did not need her mother to come crashing through a door like a storm.
"Wait," I said. "Elena. Wait. Let me go first. Let me talk to her. She is afraid, and she does not know us, and we cannot frighten her more than she already is."
Elena looked at me, and her eyes were wet, and she nodded, once, and she let me go, and I walked to the library door, and I put my hand on the handle, and I stopped, and I looked back at Rebecca.
"If you have hurt her," I said, "if you have ever hurt her, I will find out. And there will be nothing left of you when I do."
Rebecca did not answer. She stood by the desk, with her arms at her sides, and she looked at the red ring box sitting on the wood between us, and she said nothing at all.
I opened the door. And that was when I heard it. A car. An engine, slowing, stopping. Tires on the gravel of the drive.
Graham heard it too. His head came up, and his hands tightened on the briefcase, and his face went white.
"What is that?" he said.
I went to the window. I looked out at the drive, and I saw a dark SUV standing at the gate, and I saw the driver's door open, and I saw someone get out, and I felt Elena come up behind me, and I felt her hand on my shoulder, and I heard her breath catch in her throat, and I knew, before I had even seen who it was, that nothing in this house was ever going to be the same again.
Chapter 23: The SUV at the Gate
I do not remember walking to the front door. I remember the hallway, long and dim, and the portraits on the walls, my father's face, my grandfather's face, all the Hale men who had lived in this house and believed they owned it, and I remember thinking that none of them had ever owned anything that mattered, and that my father had owned less than all of them, because he had tried to own people, and people are not property, and the moment you try to own them, you lose them.