"How do you know about my scar?" she whispered.
"Because I have a photograph of you," I said. "And because your sisters have the same one. And because your mother has Elena's eyes, and you have Elena's eyes too. Your mother is Elena Hale. She is alive. She was under the pool for six years, and I found her, and now she's home, and she's waiting to meet you."
"My parents are dead," she said, but her voice shook when she said it, and I knew she had said it a hundred times before, and I knew she had never quite believed it.
"They told you that," I said gently. "The people who raised you, they were told that too. They believed it. But it isn't true. Your mother is alive. Your father is alive. Your sisters are alive. You're not alone, Grace. You've never been alone. You just didn't know it yet."
"Prove it," she said.
"Daniel," I called, and Daniel came into the kitchen, and he took the phone, and he spoke to her in his calm, steady voice, the voice he used when he was telling the truth and he knew the truth would be enough.
"Grace, my name is Daniel," he said. "I work for your father. I have the original birth records from St. Mary's Hospital. They list three children, born on the same night. Three girls. Ava, Sophie, and Grace. I have the DNA report that proves Ava and Sophie are your father's daughters. And I have the transfer papers that show a baby girl was moved to another hospital on the night she was born, on Richard Hale's orders. A baby girl who was never supposed to be found. That's you, Grace. The papers prove it. The records prove it. And your scar proves it. Will you meet us? Will you let us come to you?"
There was a long silence. I held my breath. Elena held my hand so tightly it hurt.
"Okay," Grace said at last, very quietly. "Okay. But my mum has to be there. And I want to meet my sisters first. Before the grown-ups. Is that okay?"
"That's more than okay," I said. "That's exactly how it should be."
"Tomorrow?" she asked. "After school?"
"Tomorrow," I said. "After school. We'll be there. All of us. Your mother, and Ava, and Sophie, and me. And your mum can be there too. And nobody is going to take you anywhere you don't want to go. I promise you that, Grace. I promise."
"Okay," she said. "Okay. Goodbye, Marcus."
"Goodbye, Grace," I said. "I'll see you tomorrow."
She hung up, and I sat there with the phone in my hand, and Elena was crying, and I was crying, and neither of us tried to hide it.
"She said okay," I said. "She said we could come tomorrow."
"Then tomorrow we go," Elena said. "And we bring her home."
Chapter 41: The Door
We drove the next morning, all four of us, in Daniel's car, because my car still felt like the car of a man who had almost proposed to the wrong woman, and I did not want to drive it to meet my daughter. Elena sat beside me, and Ava and Sophie sat in the back, and Ava held Sophie's hand, and Sophie held Ava's hand, and nobody said very much, because there was too much to say and no way to say it.
"Are we really going to meet her?" Ava asked. "Is she really our sister?"
"Yes," Elena said. "She really is."
"Will she like us?" Sophie asked.
"She already likes you," I said. "She drew a picture of three little girls holding hands, before she ever knew you existed. She was already looking for you."
The town was small, and the house was smaller, white with a neat garden, and the bicycle with the pink streamers was still leaning against the fence. The woman who had raised Grace opened the door before we even knocked, and she stood there, and she looked at us, all four of us standing on her pavement, and she put her hand to her mouth.
"She's inside," the woman said. "She's been standing at the window since lunch. She said she wasn't nervous, but she's been standing at the window since lunch."
"Can we come in?" Elena asked.
"Yes," the woman said. "Come in. She's waiting."
We went inside, and the living room was the same as before, small and clean, with the photographs on the mantelpiece, and there, standing in the doorway to the kitchen, was a little girl. Six years old. Elena's eyes. My father's chin. The small scar on the left eyebrow. She wore a plain dress, and her hands were clasped in front of her, and she looked at Ava, and she looked at Sophie, and she looked at me, and she looked at Elena, and she did not move.
For a moment, nobody spoke. Then Ava let go of Sophie's hand, and she took one step forward, and she said, very clearly, "Are you my sister?"
Grace looked at her. She looked at Sophie. She touched the scar on her own eyebrow, and then she looked at Ava's eyebrow, and Sophie's eyebrow, and something in her face changed, the way a door changes when someone finally turns the key.
"I think I am," she said.