She did not move. She did not speak. She looked at me, and she looked at Elena, and she looked at Ava, and I could see her thinking, I could see her trying to understand, trying to fit these new facts into the story she had been told for six years, and I could see that it did not fit, and that she did not know what to do with it.
Then Ava stepped forward, out of the doorway, down the steps, in her pink dress, and she walked across the wet gravel, and she stopped in front of Sophie, and she looked at her, and she said, in her clear, small voice, "Are you my sister?"
Sophie looked at her. She looked at the pink dress, and the dark hair, and the small scar on the left eyebrow, the same scar she had on her own, and she said, very slowly, "I think I am."
Chapter 24: I'm Sophie
Ava did not wait for permission. She never did. She reached out and took Sophie's hand, and Sophie let her, and the two of them stood there in the driveway, holding hands, two small girls in the grey afternoon light, one in a pink dress and one in a hospital gown, and they looked at each other, and they looked so alike that it hurt to see it, and I thought about the six years they had lost, and the six years they would never get back, and I thought about my father, and about what he had done, and I felt a anger rise in me so sharp and so clean that it frightened me, because it had no edge to it, and no end to it, and it was not the kind of anger that passes.
"Come inside," I said. "Both of you. Come inside, where it is warm."
I stood up, and I held out my hand to Sophie, and she looked at it for a long moment, and then she put her small hand in mine, and her fingers were cold, and her hand was so small that it disappeared inside mine, and I felt something break open in my chest, something that had been closed for six years, and I thought that this was what it felt like to find something you had believed was lost forever.
We walked back up the steps together, the four of us, Elena and Ava and Sophie and me, and Daniel followed behind us, and the man by the SUV got back into the car, and the car drove away, and the gate closed behind it, and the house was quiet again, except for the sound of our footsteps on the stone.
Inside, in the front hall, Elena knelt down in front of Sophie, slowly, so that she would not frighten her, and she looked up into her daughter's face, and her eyes were wet, and her voice was very soft.
"Hello, Sophie," she said. "I am Elena. I am your mother. I have been waiting for you for six years. I am so sorry it took so long."
Sophie looked at her. She looked at Elena's face, and she looked at her own hands, and she looked at Ava, who was still holding her other hand, and she said, in a voice so quiet it was almost a whisper, "Mom?"
Elena closed her eyes. She nodded. She did not speak, because she could not speak, and she opened her arms, and Sophie stood there for a moment, very still, and then she stepped forward, and she let Elena hold her, and Elena held her as if she would never let her go, and I stood there watching them, and I thought about the room under the pool, and the six years, and the notebook, and the drawing Ava had made, and the code Elena had taught her daughter, and I thought about how a mother who had been locked under the water for six years had still found a way to reach her children, and how a father who had believed his wife was dead had still found a way to bring her home, and how none of it should have been possible, and how all of it had happened anyway.
"I'm Sophie," the little girl said then, when Elena finally let her go, and she stood up straight, and she looked at me, and she looked at Elena, and she looked at Ava, and her voice was a little stronger now, a little steadier. "I'm Sophie Hale. And I'm your daughter."
I knelt down in front of her, the way Elena had, and I looked into her eyes, and I said, "Yes. You are. You are Sophie Hale, and you are my daughter, and you are Ava's sister, and you are Elena's daughter, and you are home now. Do you understand? You are home."
She nodded, slowly, and then she looked at Ava, and Ava looked at her, and Ava said, "Do you want to see my room? I have a pink bed. And I have a bunny. His name is Mr. Buttons. He is missing one eye, but he is still the best bunny."
Sophie looked at her, and for the first time, something like a smile moved across her face, small and uncertain, but real, and she said, "I would like to see your room."