"Marcus," she said. "Do not trust her. Do not trust the woman who calls herself Rebecca. Whatever she tells you, whatever she says about me, do not believe her. She is not who you think she is."
"I won't," I said. "I promise you. I won't."
Chapter 8: Do Not Trust Her
I went to find Rebecca that evening. She was still at the mansion. She had not left. She was sitting in the drawing room, in the same white dress, with her hands folded in her lap, and she looked up when I came in, and she smiled the way she always smiled when people were watching her.
"Marcus," she said. "Thank God you are here. I have been so worried. How is Elena? Is she all right? The doctors, what did they say?"
I did not sit down. I stood in the doorway, and I looked at her, and I thought about the keys in her hand at the edge of the pool, and the way she had shouted at me not to go down there, and the way she had said, "You can't."
"How long have you known?" I asked her.
She blinked. "Known what?"
"How long have you known that my wife was alive under my swimming pool?"
The smile stayed on her face for one more second, and then it was gone, and what was left was something cold and still, like the surface of the pool in the late afternoon.
"I don't know what you are talking about," she said. "Marcus, you are upset. You have had a terrible shock. Elena has been through something terrible, and it has affected her mind. You know that. You know how fragile she is."
"Fragile?" I said. "She survived six years in a locked room under a swimming pool. She is not fragile, Rebecca. She is the strongest person I have ever known."
"She is delusional," Rebecca said, and her voice was very calm, and very reasonable, and it was the voice of a woman who had practiced this speech. "You heard her. She thinks your father locked her up. Your father is dead, Marcus. He cannot defend himself. And now she is saying these terrible things, and you are believing her, because you want to believe her. I understand that. I do. But you must think clearly. Elena is ill. She has been ill for a long time. That is why your father kept her away. That is why he told you she died. He was protecting you. He was protecting Ava."
She stepped closer to me, and she lowered her voice, and she put her hand on my arm, the way she used to when she wanted me to listen to her, and she said, "Think about Ava, Marcus. Think about what this will do to her, if you start tearing this family apart over the words of a sick woman. She needs stability. She needs us. She needs a home that is not full of accusations and policemen."
I looked at her hand on my arm. I looked at her face. And I thought about the keys, and the hatch, and the room, and the notebook, and the drawing on the wall. I thought about six years. And I took her hand off my arm, gently, and I put it back at her side.
I stared at her. I had known this woman for years. I had been about to marry her. I had been about to kneel in front of her in front of all our friends and ask her to be my wife. And now she was sitting in my drawing room, telling me that my wife was mentally ill, and that my father had lied to me for my own good, and that I should believe her instead of believing the woman I had pulled out of the water with my own hands.
"She was not ill," I said. "She was locked in a room. There is a difference. And I saw the room, Rebecca. I went down there. I saw the bed. I saw the table. I saw the notebook. I saw Ava's drawing on the wall. A delusional woman does not keep a notebook for six years. A delusional woman does not have a daughter who sneaks down to visit her with food and a secret code."
Rebecca stood up. She smoothed her dress. She looked at me, and for a moment, something moved behind her eyes, something quick and dark, and then it was gone.
"You are making a mistake," she said. "You are going to destroy this family, Marcus. You are going to destroy everything your father built, because of a woman who has lost her mind."
"No," I said. "I am going to find out the truth. And the truth is that Elena warned me about you. She told me not to trust the woman who calls herself Rebecca. And I believe her."
I turned and walked out of the drawing room, and I did not look back. Behind me, I heard Rebecca say my name once, very quietly, and then nothing. The house was silent. The mansion was silent. And for the first time in six years, the silence did not feel empty. It felt like the beginning of something.
That night, I sat beside Elena's hospital bed, and I told her what Rebecca had said. Elena listened, and she nodded, and she did not look surprised.
"She will keep denying it," Elena said. "That is what she does. She denies, and she smiles, and she waits for you to doubt yourself. Do not doubt yourself, Marcus. You saw the room. You saw the hatch. You know what is true."