And it showed Rebecca. It showed her coming down the stairs, once, twice, three times, and it showed her standing in the doorway, looking at Elena, and it showed her turning away, and it showed her going back up the stairs, and it showed her closing the door behind her, and it showed that she had known. She had known all along. She had seen Elena down there, alive, in that room, and she had walked away, and she had said nothing, and she had come up to my house, and she had sat at my table, and she had smiled at my daughter, and she had waited for me to propose to her.
I stopped watching. I could not watch any more. I turned away from the laptop, and I looked at Elena, and she was crying, quietly, without making a sound, and I put my arms around her, and I held her, and I thought about the six years, and the room, and the water, and the lock, and I thought about how close I had come to marrying the woman who had known, and I thought about how Ava had saved us all, with her pink dress and her small, brave voice, and I thought that I would never, for as long as I lived, be able to thank my six-year-old daughter enough for what she had done.
The police finished their work. They took the briefcase, and the papers, and the laptop, and they took Graham, and they took Rebecca, and they left, and the library was quiet again, and the papers were gone from the rug, and the only thing left was the red ring box, sitting on the desk where I had put it, small and red and silent, and I picked it up, and I put it in my pocket, and I did not look at it again for a very long time.
Chapter 27: Three Days Later
Three days after the arrests, an investigator came to the hospital.
Elena was still in the hospital then, in a private room on the third floor, with a window that looked out over a small garden, and a bed that was too narrow, and a television she never watched, and a tray of food she never finished. She was thin, and she was tired, and her hands shook sometimes when she tried to hold a cup, and the doctors said she needed rest, and time, and quiet, and that six years under the water had done things to her body that would take a long time to undo. But her eyes were clear, and her mind was clear, and when the investigator came into the room with a folder under his arm, she sat up in the bed, and she looked at him, and she said, "Tell me."
I was sitting in the chair beside her bed. Ava was in the chair on the other side, swinging her legs, holding a crayon, drawing on a piece of paper. Sophie was sitting on the floor by the window, very quiet, very still, watching the garden, watching the birds, as if she were afraid that if she moved too fast, someone would notice her and take her away. The three of them, my wife and my daughters, in one small hospital room, and I looked at them, and I thought about how strange it was that this room, with its narrow bed and its small window, felt more like home than the mansion ever had.
The investigator was a man in his fifties, with grey hair and a kind face, and he sat down in the chair by the door, and he opened the folder, and he took out a stack of papers, and he laid them on the bed, and he said, "Mr. Hale. Mrs. Hale. I have the results. I thought you should see them yourselves."
The first page was the DNA report. He explained it to us, slowly, carefully, the way you explain something important to people who are tired and frightened and do not want to misunderstand. He had tested me against Ava. He had tested me against Sophie. And the results were clear. Both girls were my biological children. Both of them. Ava, and Sophie. My daughters. Both of them. There was no doubt. There was no question. The science was certain, and it said what Elena had always known, and what I had always hoped, and what my father had tried to hide: that both of my daughters were mine, and both of them were Elena's, and both of them had been born alive, on the same night, in the same hospital, six years ago.
Elena closed her eyes. She put her hand over her mouth. She did not speak for a long time. And then she said, very quietly, "Thank you. Thank you for telling me. I needed to hear it. I needed to hear someone say it out loud."
Ava looked up from her drawing. "Daddy," she said. "Does that mean Sophie is really my sister?"
"Yes," I said. "It means Sophie is really your sister. It means she always was."
Ava nodded, as if this were the most natural thing in the world, and she went back to her drawing, and Sophie, on the floor by the window, turned around, and she looked at Ava, and she looked at me, and she said, "Does that mean I can stay?"
"Yes," I said. "It means you can stay. Forever."