Brooks turned back to Lydia. "Why were you on the property?" she asked.
"I was walking nearby," Lydia said.
"Inside the backyard?" Brooks asked. Her tone did not change, but the question sharpened.
"I entered after I heard the crash," Lydia said.
Then Lydia showed them her photographs. She had her phone out, and she swiped through images as she talked. The first showed the statue already damaged, the orange mallet lying beside the fragments. The second showed me standing near the patio door with my mouth open, probably in the middle of shouting "What did you do?" The third showed the broken statue with me pointing, the tool visible in the frame. Without context, the pictures looked bad. They looked like a sequence: a man, a broken statue, a tool, a raised voice. They looked like the aftermath of exactly what Lydia was claiming.
"He became aggressive when he saw me recording," Lydia said.
Brooks turned to me. "Mr. Lawson?"
"She destroyed it," I said. My voice sounded thin to my own ears.
"Did you see her destroy it?" Brooks asked.
"I heard the crash, then came outside," I said. I wanted to give her more than that. I wanted to give her a sentence that would settle everything. But the truth was the truth, and I had not seen the moment the statue broke. I had heard it. I had run. I had found Lydia standing among the pieces.
"So you didn't physically see the moment it broke?" Brooks asked.
"No," I said.
Lydia smiled faintly. It was a small smile, almost nothing, but I saw it, and I understood what it meant. She thought that answer helped her. She thought my honesty about not seeing the blow was a gap she could stand inside. And for a moment, she was right. It did help her. For about thirty seconds, the scene belonged to her version of events: the witness with photographs, the calm voice, the man who admitted he had not seen it happen.
Then I remembered the camera.
"I have video," I said.
Lydia's smile disappeared. It did not fade. It vanished, the way a light goes out when someone pulls a plug. Brooks turned toward me.
"From where?" she asked.
"Rear security camera," I said.
Lydia spoke immediately, too fast, too sharp. "He's lying."
Mark Ellis ignored her. He did not look at her. He looked at me. "Can you access it now?" he asked.
"Yes," I said.
My hands were shaking so badly that I entered the wrong password twice. Ellis waited without comment. Brooks waited without comment. Lydia stood very still. I could feel her watching me, and I could feel the officers watching both of us, and I could feel the whole morning narrowing down to a small screen in my hands and whatever it was about to show.
That is where this part of the story pauses, because what the camera showed changed everything, and it deserves its own telling. But before I leave this scene, I want to be clear about one thing. Lydia's faint smile, in that half minute when she thought my answer had helped her, told me something I did not fully understand until much later. She had prepared for this moment. The photographs were ready. The tool was in place. The police had been called. The story was arranged. She had rehearsed her part so well that when I admitted I had not seen the blow, she believed the scene would hold. She believed the first impression would be enough. She did not know about the camera beneath the rear eave. She did not know that reality had been recorded before she ever opened her mouth. And in that half minute, smiling faintly, she believed she had already won.
What I remember most clearly about those thirty seconds is not Lydia's smile, though I remember that too. What I remember is the stillness of the garden around us. The fountain was still running, the way it always ran, a thin sound of water that had been part of my backyard for as long as I could remember. The ivy moved slightly in the breeze. The bronze pieces lay where they had fallen, catching the light in broken angles. And in the middle of all of it, two police officers stood with their notebooks out, doing their jobs the way they had been trained to do them: separate the people, listen to each person, look at what is in front of them before deciding what it means.