Lydia watched me with the phone in my hands. Her arms were still folded, but the fold had changed. Before, it had looked like confidence. Now it looked like something she was holding onto.
The screen was small, and the garden on it looked smaller, tidier, and farther away than the garden I was standing in. I scrolled backward, my thumb clumsy on the glass, past the minutes when I had been standing on the patio shouting, past the minutes when the officers had arrived, past the empty stretch of morning before any of it happened. I found the beginning and pressed play.
At 10:17 in the morning, the garden was empty.
I want to be precise about that, because precision is what saved me. The fountain was running. The ivy moved a little in the wind. The bench stood empty across from the statue. Summer Reader sat on her low wall with her book open across her lap, whole, the way she had sat for more than fifty years in my family, the way my mother had wiped rainwater from her face with a dish towel and called her the girl. Nothing was wrong. Nothing was about to be wrong, except that it was, and nobody in that picture knew it yet.
Danielle leaned in to see the screen. Mark stepped closer on my other side. Lydia stood where she was, near the gate, and I could feel her watching without looking at her. The timestamp moved forward.
At 10:21, the side gate moved.
Lydia entered alone. She carried a tote bag over one shoulder and something wrapped in a towel under her other arm. She did not hurry. She did not look around the way a person does when they have wandered somewhere by accident. She walked the way a person walks when they know exactly where they are going and have already decided what they will do when they get there. The gate closed behind her with a soft click that the camera microphone picked up, a small sound, ordinary, terrible.
Nobody spoke while we watched. On the screen, Lydia crossed the garden toward the statue, set the tote bag down on the ground, and took out the orange-handled masonry mallet. She did not drop it. She did not fumble with it. She placed it carefully behind the fountain, where it would not be in the way of what she was about to do, and where it would be waiting afterward, clean and ready to be found.
Danielle touched my arm lightly. "Can you pause there?" she asked. I did, and she leaned closer to the screen. "The tote," she said. "She brought the mallet in the tote."
Mark wrote something in his notebook. He did not look up. "And the towel-wrapped object," he said. "What was that?"
I rewound a few seconds and played it again. Lydia entered through the gate with the tote over one shoulder and something long wrapped in a towel under her other arm. The towel was light-colored, ordinary, the kind of towel anyone might own. The shape beneath it was not clear. It could have been a tool. It could have been anything. Watching it, I felt a strange, cold anger, not at the object, but at the care of it all. She had wrapped it and carried it in like a parcel, not like a person who had wandered in by accident after hearing a crash. Everything about her entrance was prepared, from the tote to the towel to the unhurried walk, and preparation is a difficult thing to explain away once it has been recorded.
"Play it on," Danielle said quietly.
Then she reached into the tote again and took out a second tool.
The camera angle does not show exactly what it is. I have watched that footage many times since, and I have never been able to say more than that. It is a tool, dark against the tote, held in her gloved hand. It does not matter what it was. What matters is what she did with it.
She struck the statue once. The sound came through the small camera microphone, thin and far away and unmistakable, stone against stone, or metal against stone, something heavy breaking. She struck it a second time. The figure tipped. The base broke. She struck the pieces again, and again, not wildly, not in a frenzy, but steadily, the way a person works through a task they have already decided to finish.