Margaret's call about the roof stayed with me longer than any of the legal letters. She did not call to celebrate. She called the way a person calls to report that something ordinary has finally been fixed, with a practical satisfaction in her voice that had nothing to do with triumph. A roof, she said, and then she laughed a little, as if she were surprised at herself for being pleased about something so unglamorous. I understood. After months of appraisals and attributions and foundry marks, a roof was something you could stand under. It kept the rain out. It did not require interpretation. I told her I was glad, and I meant it in a way that went beyond politeness. Her roof was proof that at least one part of the damage had been repaired in a form she could actually live under, which was more than most of the case had offered anyone.
The news cycle moved on eventually, as news cycles do. The two mallets stopped appearing in every story. New headlines replaced the old ones. People online found other details to obsess over. I did not mind the fading attention. Attention had never been what I wanted from any of this. What I wanted, from the morning I found the statue broken, was for the record to be correct. The record, by then, was correct, and correctness does not need an audience to remain true.
I saw Lydia once after the case ended. Not at court. At a mediation connected to insurance recovery. She sat across the hallway from me, and for nearly an hour neither of us spoke. The hallway was quiet in the way institutional hallways are quiet, with carpet that swallowed footsteps and a clock that seemed louder than it should have been. I watched her hands. She kept them folded in her lap, then unfolded them, then folded them again. I did not know what I wanted from that meeting. I knew only that I was not going to be the one to break the silence first. Part of me wanted an apology that matched the size of the damage, and another part knew no apology could. I thought about the morning she smiled at me in my garden, and about the months since, and about how strange it was to be sitting across a hallway from the person who had done it, both of us dressed carefully, both of us pretending that a mediation room was a normal place for two people to meet. It was not normal. Nothing about the situation was normal. But the hallway demanded a kind of politeness anyway, and we both obeyed it, the way people obey the rules of a waiting room even when they are waiting for very different things. I told myself I was not nervous. I was, a little, though not in the way I had been nervous on the destruction morning. That nervousness had been sharp and physical. This was quieter: the nervousness of a person about to hear something he cannot unhear, and not knowing whether he wants to hear it.
Then she stood.
"Mr. Lawson," she said.
I looked up.
"I'm sorry."
I did not answer immediately. The words hung there, small and inadequate against the size of what she had done, and I let them hang, because I had earned the right to take my time.
She continued: "I didn't understand what the statue meant to you."
That irritated me, and I did not hide it. "You didn't need to," I said.
She stopped. For a moment I thought she might sit back down. Then she said, very quietly, "It could have meant nothing."
"It was still mine," I said.
She nodded. "You're right."
I asked the question I had carried since the morning she smiled at me in my garden. "Did Julian tell you to frame me?"
She hesitated, and the hesitation told me more than a quick answer would have. Then she said, "He told me the damage needed a believable owner explanation."
"That's not the same question," I said.
"No," she said. She looked toward the floor. "The duplicate tool was my idea."
"Why?" I asked.
"Because I had photographed your garage."
"First time you came?" I said.
"Yes."
"You said insurance."
"I lied."
"Obviously," I said.
She took a breath. "I thought if police saw something that looked like yours, they would treat your anger differently."
"What anger?" I asked.
"The anger you'd have when you saw the statue broken."