Lydia, with her own interests in reducing her legal exposure, cooperated. Her statement was direct, and I believe it was direct because directness was the only thing she had left to trade. She said Julian told her the statue needed to become unusable for comparison. He did not specify exactly how. That sentence stayed with me too. "Needed to become unusable for comparison." Not "should be examined." Not "should be questioned." Unusable. For comparison. Because comparison was the danger. Elaine had explained it to me by then, and I will come back to that, but the heart of it was simple: if Summer Reader could be examined cleanly, measured, compared, tested against the other Voss garden bronzes, then experts could see traits that matched, traits that would let them look back at other pieces Cross had classified and ask whether he had known, or should have known, what they were before he bought them cheaply. An intact statue was a reference point. A broken statue was not. A broken statue, photographed beside a tool that looked like mine, was something else entirely: it was a distraction with a suspect attached.
Lydia said she first proposed staging an accident. The record shows the accident idea was dropped, and the reason tells you something about how Lydia thought. An accident is hard to control. An accident leaves questions about timing and physics and luck. An intentional-destruction story, told by a witness who arrived with photographs and a police call already planned, is stronger, because it gives everyone a person to blame and a motive to attach to that person. She needed a story that would hold together in the first ten minutes, in the driveway, in front of officers who had just arrived and had not yet seen any video. An accident does not do that. A furious owner does.
And that was where the refused second offer came in, or rather, where Lydia thought it came in. The record says she believed investigators and insurers might believe Henry became angry after learning the sculpture was disputed. Cross had approached me more than once about buying the statue. The documented, quoted offer was the $52,000 written offer, and I had declined it, and Julian had replied within twelve minutes claiming the piece was likely a later decorative casting. Lydia's thinking, as investigators reconstructed it from her statements and messages, was that a man who had refused to sell, and who had then been told his statue might be a reproduction, might be angry enough to destroy it. That was the motive she wanted people to infer. It did not matter that it was wrong in a specific and important way: my own experts had never told me the statue was fake. Only Cross had claimed that. Julia had called his conclusion premature. Elaine had told me not to sign anything and had refused to speculate before testing. Nobody I trusted had said the word reproduction about Summer Reader. So Lydia planned to supply the motive herself. She would create the anger, or at least the appearance of it, by breaking the thing I loved in front of me and then photographing my reaction.
There was one more piece of the plan that investigators found, and it chilled me more than almost anything else, because it showed how carefully she had thought about my feelings before she ever touched the statue. She drafted an anonymous email, addressed to me, that police later found unsent. It read: "The museum has concluded your statue is a reproduction. You've wasted everyone's time."
She planned to send it shortly before destroying the sculpture. Think about that order. First the email, telling me that the museum, the institution I trusted, had concluded my mother's statue was a reproduction, that I had wasted everyone's time. Then the destruction. Then the photographs. Then the police. The email was meant to arrive before the breaking, so that by the time officers arrived, there would already be a reason in the air for me to be furious. It was meant to plant the motive before the crime, the way she planted the mallet before the breaking. It was a small, cruel piece of stage management, and I am grateful, in a strange way, that she changed her mind. She abandoned the email because it left too much electronic trail. A sent email can be traced. A sent email has a sender, a time, a server. She understood that, and she chose a plan with fewer traces instead. Break the statue. Plant the tool. Photograph me angry. Call the police. Claim she witnessed the destruction. Let everyone infer the motive. No email required. The anger would be real enough on its own, because she was going to break something I loved and then stand there smiling while I discovered it.