I sat down on the bench. It was the same bench my mother had sat on every evening for months after my father died, looking across at the girl. I had not thought about that when I sat down. I thought about it a second later, and then I thought about my mother wiping rainwater from the book in the statue's hands with one of her old dish towels, and about the way she used to say, "Wash the girl before your aunt comes," as if the statue were a child who needed to look presentable for company. I thought about her standing beside the sculpture in 1986 in gardening gloves, her hair looking terrible, a photograph I loved precisely because she would have hated it in a museum.
Julia sat beside me. She did not touch my arm. She did not offer the kind of sentence people offer when they want the sadness to pass quickly. She just sat there, and the garden was quiet in the way gardens are quiet after something loud has happened in them.
After a while I asked the only question that seemed to matter. "Can it be restored?"
Elaine did not lie to me. She had never lied to me, not about the value, not about the waiting, not about anything, and she did not start then. "Possibly," she said.
"Completely?" I asked.
"No," she said.
I nodded. I had expected that answer and still needed to hear it said out loud. Part of me had been holding on to a version of the afternoon in which someone who knew bronze could put the girl back together and hand her back to me the way she had been. That version was not available.
Elaine crouched near the broken base. She moved the way conservators move, slowly, without reaching for anything before she had looked at it from three angles. She asked for gloves and a flashlight. Julia handed them to her from the bag Elaine always carried, the same bag she had brought on her first visit, when she spent almost three hours in my garden photographing the base and measuring casting seams and examining old surface wear and looking beneath the edge with a flashlight.
She had looked beneath the edge then, too, and photographed a small foundry mark at the bottom of the base, partially hidden by decades of corrosion. I remembered her saying corrosion had made it difficult to read completely.
Now the break had changed the geometry of the thing. The base was split, and the split had opened a section of the underside that had been sealed against the ground and against time for decades. Elaine directed the flashlight into the exposed surface, and her expression changed. Her mouth tightened slightly. Her eyes narrowed. She leaned closer, adjusted the angle of the light, and then she looked up at me.
"Henry," she said.
I stood up from the bench. Julia stood with me.
Elaine pointed the flashlight again, steady this time, and said, "This is original."
I asked, "You're sure?"
She said, "I'm much more sure than I was yesterday."
I stood there trying to understand what she meant, and then I understood it all at once, and the understanding arrived with a feeling I did not expect, which was something close to laughter, except it was not funny at all. The woman who had come into my garden to destroy the statue had, by breaking it, exposed the very thing she apparently wanted destroyed. She had wanted to remove an intact Voss piece from clean examination. Instead she had cracked open the base and given Elaine a clearer view of the foundry mark than corrosion had ever allowed. The destruction had not hidden the evidence. It had revealed it.
That was the first irony. I did not have a name for the second one yet. I thought about Lydia placing her tool, striking the figure, striking the pieces again, wiping the duplicate mallet, placing it beside the fragments, calling someone, calling the police, telling her story. I thought about how carefully she had prepared every piece of that morning, and how one of those pieces, the breaking itself, had undone the purpose of all the rest. She had needed the statue gone, or at least unusable. What she had produced instead was a broken statue that could now be examined in ways an intact one, sitting on its base in my garden, could not have been examined without someone deciding to move it or disturb it. She had done Elaine's work for her, in the worst possible way, and for the worst possible reason.