The sirens stopped. Car doors closed out front. Voices carried around the side of the house, low and professional, and I knew the officers would be coming through the gate in a moment, and that the woman would be there to meet them, and that whatever she said first would matter. I did not know yet what she would say. I did not know about the photographs, or the video, or the phone call, or any of the rest of it. I only knew what I had seen with my own eyes: a woman in a cream-colored jacket standing in the middle of my garden, a shattered statue at her feet, a mallet that looked like mine lying beside it, and a smile that told me she had planned every part of it, including the part where I came outside and found her there.
I looked once more at the pieces on the grass, and I made myself look properly, because I knew that later I would be asked what I had seen, and I wanted to remember it exactly. The open book was still across the figure's lap, but part of it was gone, broken off with the arm that had held it. The base, which had always looked so solid, so permanent, was split in a way that made no sense until you understood that someone had hit it again and again, not once, but deliberately, until it gave way. The head, on its side in the ivy, faced away from me, and I was glad of that, because I did not want to see the face looking up at the sky with the rest of her in pieces around it. The fountain kept running behind everything, thin and steady, and the sound of it, which had always been pleasant, now sounded thin in a different way, like something continuing out of habit after the reason for it had gone.
I thought about the bench across from the statue, where my mother had sat every evening for months after my father died. I thought about how she would sit there with her hands in her lap, not reading, not gardening, just sitting, with the girl in front of her and the maple tree overhead and the ivy moving a little in the evening air. I had never asked her what she thought about during those evenings. I had been younger then, and busy, and I had assumed there would be time to ask later. There is a particular kind of regret that comes from realizing you never asked a simple question, and standing in that garden with the statue in pieces, I felt it all at once, sharp and useless. She was gone. My father was gone. And now the thing they had both lived with, the thing my mother had wiped clean with a dish towel and talked to as if it were a member of the household, was broken on the grass, and a stranger in a cream-colored jacket was walking to meet the police as if she had done nothing at all.
I did not move. I did not touch the fragments. I did not pick up the mallet. I stood in my socks on the damp patio and watched the side gate, and I listened to the voices out front getting closer, and I tried to hold on to the exact order of what had happened, because I already had a feeling, though I could not have said why, that the order of things was going to matter more than anything else. The crash. The run to the door. The woman standing there. The smile. The sentence about explaining. The mallet. The second smile. The sirens. The phone. The word "Good." The walk to the gate. I repeated it to myself like a list, the way you repeat a phone number you are afraid of forgetting, and I kept my hands in my pockets so they would stop shaking, and I waited for whatever was going to happen next.