Danielle Brooks did not look at Lydia again right away. She looked at me, and her face had the flat, careful expression of someone who has just heard two people tell her opposite things and is waiting to see which one of them starts making mistakes first. Mark Ellis stood a little to her left, his notebook open, his pen not moving. Lydia was still standing near the side gate with her arms folded, as if she owned the right to be there, as if she had only stepped in to help.
"I heard the crash, then came outside," I said. My voice sounded strange to me, too even, the way a voice sounds when a person is trying very hard not to shout.
"So you didn't physically see the moment it broke?" Danielle asked.
"No," I said. I hated saying it. It was true, and it was the only true thing in the garden that was going to sound like a weakness.
Lydia smiled faintly. It was a small smile, the kind that does not reach the eyes, and I understood in that instant that she had been counting on exactly that answer. She had built her whole morning around the gap between what I heard and what I saw. She thought the gap was wide enough to stand in.
Then I remembered the camera.
It was the ordinary, practical thought of a man who had spent a weekend running a cable beneath a roofline because a stranger had been photographing his fence. I had almost forgotten it was there, the way you forget a smoke detector until it goes off. I said it out loud before I had finished thinking it through.
"I have video."
Lydia's smile disappeared. It did not fade. It went, all at once, the way a light goes when someone pulls a plug. Her mouth closed. Her eyes went to Danielle's face, then to Mark's, then back to me, and for the first time that morning she looked like a person who had not planned the next thirty seconds.
"He's lying," she said quickly. Too quickly. The words came out before Danielle had even finished turning toward me.
Danielle did not answer her. She looked at me and said, "From where?"
"Rear security camera," I said. "Under the back eave. It points at the garden."
Mark ignored Lydia completely. He had the stillness of a man who has learned not to chase every interruption. "Can you access it now?" he asked.
"Yes," I said. "On my phone."
My hands were shaking so badly that I could barely hold the phone steady. I had not noticed the shaking until I tried to type. I typed my password and got it wrong. The phone buzzed its small, patient refusal. I typed it again and got it wrong a second time, and for a terrible second I was afraid the phone would lock me out and Lydia would be right in front of two police officers, telling them I was making the whole thing up.
"Take your time, sir," Danielle said. Her voice was calm in a way that steadied me more than any reassurance could have. I breathed once, slowly, and typed the password a third time, one digit at a time, watching each number appear. The feed loaded.
I had installed that camera myself, on a Saturday three weeks earlier, after the phone call with Julian Cross in which he told me, in that careful past tense of his, that Lydia Crane had only worked for him once, long ago, and had nothing to do with him now. I did not believe him, but I also did not know what else to do with not believing him, so I did the practical thing. I already had a camera covering the patio and a second one covering the garage. I bought a third, a small white box, and I mounted it beneath the rear eave, high enough and tucked far enough beneath the roofline that most people would not notice it unless they were looking for it. It was not hidden like spy equipment. It was simply unobtrusive, the way a smoke detector is unobtrusive, and I had run the cable myself along the eave and through the attic hatch, scraping one knuckle on a rafter and swearing quietly about it, the way you do with any small job around an old house. I had tested it that evening, then forgotten about it. Standing in my garden with two police officers and a woman who had just accused me of destroying my own statue, I was suddenly very glad I had not forgotten it completely.