It lay beside the broken base, bright and obvious against the grass and the bronze fragments. An orange-handled masonry mallet. My stomach tightened in a way I can still feel when I think about it, because I owned one almost exactly like it. Same general size. Same dark rubber grip. Same bright orange handle. Mine sat on a shelf in the garage beside an old set of chisels, where it had sat for years, and I knew, without having to go and check, that this one was not mine. It was too clean. It was too new. But it was close enough that anyone walking into that garden would think it was mine, and that was the point. I understood that even then, with my thoughts still coming in pieces. The mallet was not dropped accidentally. It was there for me to notice.
The woman followed my eyes. She saw me look at the mallet, and she smiled again, as if I had just done exactly what she expected me to do. That smile told me more than anything else she said that morning. It told me the scene had been arranged. It told me I was not looking at an accident, or at a crime of passion, or at something that had gotten out of hand. I was looking at something that had been thought through in advance, and I was standing in the middle of it.
Then I heard the sirens.
They were still far off at first, a thin sound coming from the direction of the street, and the woman turned her head toward it the way a person turns toward a bus they have been expecting. She took out her phone, calmly, without hurrying, and she said one word into it, or to herself, or to no one in particular:
"Good."
A patrol car stopped in front of the house. Then another. I could hear the doors, the radios, the sound of boots on the front walk, and the woman walked toward the side gate as if she had been waiting for them all along, as if this were the next step in a plan she had already written out. She did not look back at the statue. She did not look at me. She walked calmly to meet the police, and as I watched her go, the last piece of the morning fell into place in my mind.
She had not only destroyed the statue. She had already called the police.
I stayed right where I was. I did not follow her to the gate. I did not pick up any of the pieces. I think some part of me, the part that had spent years watching police shows and listening to people who knew better than I did, understood that I should not touch anything, even though every instinct I had was pulling me toward the grass to gather up what was left of her. The girl. That was what my mother had always called her, and standing there with the fountain running and the sirens getting louder, I heard my mother's voice in my head as clearly as if she were standing on the patio behind me, telling me to wash the girl before my aunt came, to trim the ivy around the girl, to not let the sprinkler hit the girl all night. She had spent most of her adult life improving that garden, and the statue had been the center of it, not because it was valuable, but because it belonged there, beside the fountain, facing the maple tree and the bench where she used to sit.
I looked down at the fragments again. The arm that had held the open book was gone from the shoulder, lying a few feet away in the ivy. The head rested on its side, the face turned toward the grass, and I could not bring myself to turn it over. The base was split clean through in one place and cracked in another, and small bronze-colored pieces were scattered like something that had been dropped from a height, except nothing had dropped. Someone had stood in my garden and broken her apart, piece by piece, and then had stood there waiting for me to find her.
My hands were shaking. I put them in my pockets so I would not have to look at them. The socks I was wearing were damp from the patio, and the morning air was cool against my face, and all of those small, ordinary sensations kept arriving one after another, as if my body were trying to prove to me that the world was still normal while my eyes were telling me it was not. The maple tree moved a little in the wind. A bird called from somewhere beyond the fence. The lavender bed gave off its smell where it had been trampled, sharp and clean. I thought about the fact that I had walked past this statue a thousand times without really seeing her, the way you walk past anything that has always been there, and I thought about how, in a single morning, she had gone from being a permanent part of the garden to being a collection of broken pieces that I was afraid to touch.