A week later, a letter arrived. It was not an email. It was a proper letter, on heavy paper, with the Cross Heritage letterhead at the top. Inside was a written offer: fifty-two thousand dollars for Summer Reader. I read it twice, standing at the kitchen counter, because the number seemed both large and small at the same time. Large, because it was more money than anyone had ever offered me for anything in my yard. Small, because I did not yet know what the statue might be worth.
I called Elaine.
"Don't sign anything," she said, before I had finished the sentence.
"Is fifty-two thousand low?" I asked.
"If this is what I think it is," she said, "dramatically."
"How dramatically?"
"I don't want to speculate before testing," she said. That was Elaine all over. Careful. Precise. Unwilling to give a number she could not defend. But the word she had used stayed with me. Dramatically. Not a little low. Not somewhat low. Dramatically.
I wrote Julian a short email that evening. I thanked him for the offer and declined it. I kept the language plain. I did not explain myself. I did not mention Elaine or Julia or the testing. I simply said no.
He replied within twelve minutes.
I remember the time because I was still sitting at the kitchen table when the notification came through, and I remember thinking that twelve minutes was fast for a man who ran a business and supposedly had to consider things. His reply was polite, like his voice had been. He wrote that he understood. Then he added his preliminary view: the piece was likely a later decorative casting rather than an original Voss lifetime cast, and his offer reflected risk.
I read that sentence three times. A later decorative casting. Not an original. A copy, more or less, made after the fact, worth a fraction of the real thing. And I kept coming back to the same question: how had he reached a preliminary view at all? He had never seen the statue. He had never set foot in my garden. He had never held a flashlight to the base or measured a casting seam or looked at the surface wear the way Elaine had. He had not even seen a photograph from me, because I had not sent him one.
I forwarded his email to Julia.
She called me immediately. Her voice was sharper than usual, the way a person's voice gets when something has crossed a line they care about.
"Has Cross seen the statue?" she asked.
"No."
"Did you send photographs?"
"No."
"Then that conclusion is premature," she said. She said it flatly, like a verdict.
"Do you know him?" I asked.
There was a pause. Not a long one, but a real one, the kind of pause that tells you the answer is complicated.
"Yes," she said.
"Is that good?"
Another pause. "Cross Heritage has handled legitimate material." She chose her words the way Elaine chose hers, carefully, as if each one had weight and she did not want to drop any of them.
"What aren't you saying?" I asked.
"I'm saying wait for the independent review," she said.
I did wait. Elaine was doing her work. Julia was doing hers. The museum was preparing its exhibition, and my statue, the girl my mother had wiped clean with a dish towel, was suddenly a piece of evidence in a story much larger than my backyard. I tried to live my ordinary life around that fact. I sat on the bench in the evenings, and I looked at the statue and tried to see her the way other people suddenly saw her: not just a garden ornament, but a possible original, a missing cast, a thing with a number attached to it.
About a month before the destruction, I found a woman near my side gate taking photographs through the fence.
It was a weekday afternoon. I had come home early, and I was carrying groceries in from the car when I noticed her. She was standing just outside the gate, holding a camera up to the fence slats, angling it toward the garden. She was not trying to hide, exactly, but she was not behaving like someone with a reason to be there either. She had the calm, practiced manner of a person doing a job.
"Can I help you?" I asked.
She lowered the camera. "I'm documenting the landscaping," she said.
"For who?"