Danielle picked it up carefully, turning it in her gloved hands. The grip was cracked, and the crack had been repaired with silver tape, the tape gone a little gray at the edges with age and use. She set it down on the workbench. Then Mark brought in the other one, the planted mallet, sealed in a bag, and set it beside mine.
They were the same general model. That was the first thing anyone would notice, and it was the thing Lydia had been counting on. Same bright orange handle. Same size. Same shape. From a few feet away, in a chaotic garden, with a broken statue between you and the tool, you would not look twice. You would think, as I had thought when I first saw it beside the base, that it was mine.
Up close, they were not the same at all. Mine had the cracked grip and the silver tape repair. The planted one had black tape, neat and new, wrapped where a grip would wear. The wear was different. Mine had the nicks and dullness of a tool that had actually been used, year after year, on real work. The planted one looked used in a general way, scuffed enough to pass, but the scuffs were in the wrong places, too even, too deliberate, like someone had tried to make a new thing look old without knowing which parts of an old thing actually get worn. The serial markings were different too. Danielle noted them both, photographing each mallet from several angles, measuring, writing, being thorough in the way that people are thorough when they know a detail will matter later.
Mark held a ruler beside each handle in turn while Danielle photographed, and I watched the two tools the way a man watches two photographs of the same person taken years apart, looking for the small differences that tell you they are not the same person at all. My mallet's handle had darkened where my hand had gripped it over the years, and the orange had gone slightly duller at the edges, the way bright things do when they live in a garage and get used. The planted mallet's orange was brighter, newer, and the scuffs on it sat on the surface rather than in it, as if someone had roughed it up quickly to make it look worked. My mallet's grip crack ran along the grain of the rubber where the material had aged and split, and the silver tape over it had been wrapped by my own hand, a little unevenly, with one corner lifting where I had pressed it down and it had not quite stayed. The planted mallet's black tape was wrapped tightly and evenly, with no lifting corner, no graying at the edges, no sign of a hand that had wrapped it in a hurry years ago and then forgotten about it. The chisels beside them on the shelf, my father's old set, sat undisturbed, and I thought about how Lydia must have stood at that garage window a month earlier and looked at this shelf, at my mallet among my father's tools, and decided that a copy would be enough. She had not needed it to be exact. She had needed it to be close, and close, in a garden full of broken bronze and shouting, is usually enough. It was only not enough here because Danielle did not stop at close. She measured. She photographed. She wrote down the markings. She treated the difference between two mallets as seriously as the difference between two stories, and that seriousness was what the whole morning had been missing until she arrived.
Someone had seen my mallet, or photographed it. I thought about Lydia standing outside my side gate a month earlier, holding her camera, telling me she was documenting landscaping for insurance. There is a garage window visible from that angle. She had not been photographing landscaping. She had been photographing tools. She had looked through that window and seen my mallet on its shelf, and she had gone and found one close enough to pass for it in the first ten minutes of a chaotic morning.