Watching that, I felt something I had not felt when I first came outside and found the statue broken. When I first came outside, I had felt shock, and then anger, and then the strange, hollow confusion of being accused of something I had not done. Watching the video, I felt something quieter and worse: the recognition that none of it had been sudden. On the screen, Lydia did not lose her temper. She did not act in a moment of passion. She worked. She struck, paused, assessed, and struck again, the way a person demolishes something they have already decided is in the way. The figure tipping was not an accident. The base breaking was not collateral damage; it was part of the job, because the base was where the comparison lived, where the foundry mark hid beneath decades of corrosion. She was not breaking a statue in anger. She was removing a document, one blow at a time, and doing it carefully enough that the pieces would be too broken to put back together into anything an expert could examine cleanly.
She stopped. She looked toward the house. She waited.
I remember that wait. On the screen it lasts only a short time, but watching it, I felt every second of it, because I knew what she was waiting for. She was waiting for me. She was waiting for the man whose house this was to come outside and find his statue broken and become angry in front of witnesses. When I did not appear immediately, she hit the remains again, harder, and that was the crash I heard. That was the sound that shook the kitchen windows and made me drop my coffee mug and run for the back door.
Then, on the video, she did something that told me more about her plan than the breaking itself. She set her real tool back inside the tote, carefully, the way a person puts away something they intend to keep. She walked behind the fountain, picked up the orange mallet, wiped it with a cloth, and placed it beside the broken statue. She arranged it. She did not throw it down. She placed it where a person arriving afterward would see it and think, without having to be told, that it belonged to the scene. She stepped back and looked at her work.
Danielle paused the video.
Nobody moved. The garden around us was very quiet. The fountain was still running. The broken statue lay where it had always stood, except that it did not stand anymore. Lydia stood near the gate with her arms no longer folded, her hands hanging at her sides, her face the color of paper.
Mark looked at her. His voice was even, almost gentle, which made it worse for her, I think, because there was nowhere in it for her to argue with.
"You want to change anything you told us?" he asked.
Lydia's face had gone pale. She looked at the phone in my hand, at the frozen image on its screen, at Danielle, at Mark, and then at the ground. When she spoke, her voice was smaller than it had been all morning, and it was, I realized later, the smartest sentence she said all day.
"I need an attorney."
Danielle nodded once, as if she had expected exactly that sentence. She did not ask another question. She turned to Mark, and something passed between them that I did not need to understand to recognize: the part of the morning that belonged to questions was over, and the part that belonged to procedure had begun. Mark spoke to Lydia, and she nodded, and another officer led her toward the side gate, away from the garden, away from the fragments, away from the phone in my hand with the frozen image still on its screen.
My hands had stopped shaking. I noticed it when I lowered the phone and saw it was steady in my grip. The shaking had been there since I first came outside and found Lydia standing among the pieces of Summer Reader, and it left the way a fever breaks, all at once, without ceremony. In its place was a tiredness that went straight through me, into my legs and my shoulders, the tiredness of a man holding himself upright by force for an hour.