I went up to the attic, to the boxes my mother had kept, boxes full of the ordinary paperwork of a life: garden expenses, paint receipts, repair bills, a note about a used lawn mower, all of it boring in the way that family papers are boring until suddenly they are not. I sat on the attic floor for a long time, going through those boxes one by one, and I kept finding small things that stopped me: a photograph of my parents in the garden when they were young, my father's handwriting on the back of an envelope, a list my mother had made of plants she wanted to try the following spring and never got around to planting. The attic smelled of dust and old paper and cedar, and the light coming through the small window was the color of late afternoon, and I remember thinking that this was what a family actually leaves behind, not the big things, but the boxes full of small things that nobody thinks are important until someone comes looking for one particular piece of paper. And there, in my grandfather's notebook, I found the line. It was dated October 1951, and it said, in his plain handwriting: "Voss garden figure, purchased Channing estate, 275." Two hundred and seventy-five dollars. That was what he had paid for her, in 1951, from the Channing estate, and beside the notebook was a folded receipt that had survived all those years in the same box. Seller: Channing Estate Services. Description: "Bronze seated reader, A. Voss." I sat there for a while with the notebook open on my lap, looking at that line, and I thought about my grandfather, a man I had known mostly through stories and photographs, standing in someone else's garden or estate sale in 1951 and deciding to spend two hundred and seventy-five dollars on a bronze girl reading a book, and bringing her home, and putting her beside a fountain, where she stayed for more than fifty years while the world changed around her.
I brought both of them downstairs and showed them to Elaine, and she looked at them for a long time, turning the receipt over in her hands, reading the notebook line twice, and then she said:
"This is very helpful."
I asked her what she meant, and she said, with a dryness that I would come to recognize as her way of saying something serious without making a speech out of it:
"Helpful like stop leaving it completely unattended."
I laughed at the time, because it sounded like a joke, and because I did not yet understand how serious she was. The statue had been in my garden for more than fifty years. It had survived weather and seasons and the ordinary neglect that comes with living in a house full of memories. It had never occurred to me that it needed guarding, or that anyone would want it badly enough to come into my garden and break it. I thought the hardest part of owning something rare would be learning how to take care of it. I did not know that the hardest part would be learning that other people had already noticed it, and that one of them had already decided what to do about it. That thought stayed with me after Elaine left, quiet and uncomfortable, like a sound you hear in another room of the house late at night and cannot quite place, something that might be nothing at all, or might be the first sign that you are not as alone as you believed.
My mother appears in a photograph from 1986, standing beside the sculpture in gardening gloves, her hair looking terrible, and I loved that photograph more than any of the formal pictures we had of her, because it showed her the way she actually was in that garden: practical, a little untidy, completely at home. She would have been furious to know that photograph might end up in a museum someday. Her hair looked terrible. That was the kind of thing she cared about, and the kind of thing I loved her for caring about. The statue, in that photograph, looks exactly the way it looked on the morning it was destroyed, before it was destroyed: a young woman sitting on a low wall with a book open across her lap, facing the maple tree, with ivy at her feet and the fountain behind her, and my mother standing beside her like a friend.