The sheriff's car came into the lot at about a quarter to three, moving slowly past the rows of parked cars, and it stopped at the edge of the crowd, and the crowd parted for it the way crowds part for authority when it arrives in a form they recognize. Sheriff Donna Fields got out, fifty four years old, tall, graying hair pulled back, uniform neat, and she stood for a moment beside her car and took in the whole scene with one long look, the way a person does when she has walked into the middle of something and needs to understand it before she speaks. She saw the old man in cuffs beside the silver Lexus, and the deputy standing close to him, and the second deputy standing behind, and the woman with the phone, and the store manager at the glass doors, and the son standing at the edge of the ring, and the shoppers with their carts, and she saw, too, the papers in the old man's cuffed hands, and the groceries in the trunk, and the calm on the old man's face, and something in her own face tightened, just a little, as she took it all in.
She walked toward the car, not fast and not slow, and she did not speak to Sullivan first. She walked past him, and she stopped beside the Lexus, and she looked at the plate on the back of the car, and she looked at it the way a person looks at something she intends to remember exactly, and then she turned to Clarence and asked his name, and Clarence gave it, steady and clear, Clarence Webb, and she asked him whose car it was, and he said it was his, and that he had bought it new eight years ago, and that the registration was in his hand, and she nodded, and she asked him to hold the papers up where she could see them, and he did, and she read them. Sullivan started to speak, to explain, to tell her what he had done and why, and Fields held up one hand without looking at him, and he stopped talking, and the lot went quiet enough that Irene could hear her own breathing.
Fields read the plate herself, digit by digit, slowly, out loud, in a voice that carried across the lot, and she read it a second time, and she wrote it down in her notebook, and then she read the registration in Clarence's hand, and she compared the two, and the crowd watched her do it, and no one spoke, and even Sullivan stood still. She walked around the car once, slowly, and she looked at the front plate as well, and she read that too, and she wrote that down, and she stood for a moment with her notebook in her hand, and she looked at Sullivan, and she looked at Harper, and she looked at Clarence, and the afternoon seemed to hold its breath. Anthony watched her from the edge of the ring, and he felt his heart beating hard, and he thought about all the things he had wanted to say, and he said none of them, because the sheriff was doing what needed to be done, and because for the first time since he had arrived, someone in uniform was reading the papers.
Fields asked Sullivan for the report, and Sullivan gave it, and she read it, and she read the plate number in the report, and she read the plate on the car again, and she said nothing for a long moment, and the silence stretched, and Irene kept filming, and Steve Ball watched from the doors, and Harper stood with his eyes on the ground. Then Fields spoke, and her voice was calm and level, and she said that the plate on the car and the plate in the report did not match, and that one digit was different, and that the difference mattered, and that she would check it once more before she said anything else, and she bent down and read the plate a third time, slowly, and she nodded to herself, and she closed her notebook, and she turned to Sullivan, and she told him to step back from the old man, and Sullivan stepped back, and the ring of shoppers seemed to lean forward all at once. She told Harper to stand by, and she told the crowd that the matter was now in her hands, and she turned back to Clarence, and she asked him if he was hurt, and Clarence said that he was not hurt, and that his wrists were sore, and that he only wanted the cuffs off and his papers back in his own hands, and Fields said that was fair, and that it would be done, and that she was sorry it had taken so long for someone to read what he had been holding out all afternoon.
Fields turned then to the crowd, and she asked that anyone who had filmed the afternoon keep the video safe and delete nothing, and Irene stepped forward and said that she had filmed it all, and that she still held her phone. Fields thanked her and asked her name, and Irene gave it, and Fields wrote it down. Then Fields looked toward the store doors, where Steve Ball stood watching, and she asked him to keep the store camera footage safe, and Steve nodded and said that it was being saved.