Chapter Eight
The Phone in the Other Hand
Clarence had carried a phone for years without ever quite trusting it. Dorothy had been the one who loved the small screen and its pictures, and after she died he had kept the phone charged out of habit, the way he kept her chair at the table for a month before he could bring himself to move it. His son Anthony had shown him, patiently, how to open the camera and press the red circle, and Clarence had practiced on the birds at the feeder until the motion felt natural in his hand. He had never expected to use it on a man. He had never expected to need it. But standing in the Meijer lot with his papers on the roof of his car and a deputy's handcuffs swinging in the sun, Clarence understood, with a clarity that surprised him, that the phone was the only witness he could be sure of.
He lifted it slowly, with his left hand, keeping his right hand open and visible at his side. He did not raise it fast, and he did not raise it high. He held it at chest height, the way Anthony had taught him, and he pressed the red circle, and he saw the small light that meant it was recording. Then he said, in the same steady voice he had used all afternoon, that he was recording, and that he was doing so because he wanted a true account of what was happening, and that he would keep recording until the afternoon was over. He said it plainly, without triumph and without threat, because it was neither. It was a fact, offered the way he offered all facts, and he let it stand in the air between them.
Sullivan's face changed. The finger, which had dropped while he handled the handcuffs, came up again, and this time it pointed at the phone, and his voice rose over the sound of the lot. He told Clarence to stop recording, and he told him to put the phone down, and he said the phone would be taken if Clarence did not put it down himself. Clarence kept the phone where it was. He said he had a right to record, and he said he was standing in a public lot, in the open sun, and he said the phone was staying in his hand. He said it quietly, and he was surprised at how quiet his own voice sounded, and how steady, as if the phone had lent him a second steadiness to go with the first.
The deputy took a step toward the phone, and Clarence took a half step back, keeping the distance between them, keeping the phone between them, keeping his own body between the phone and the deputy's reaching hand. He had no plan beyond the recording. He had no speech prepared. He only knew that the afternoon had already gone wrong in one way that could not be undone, which was the refusal to read, and he did not want it to go wrong in a second way, which would have been the loss of the record. He thought of Dorothy again, who had filmed everything, birthdays and birds and ordinary Tuesdays, and who had said that a picture kept what memory let go. He kept the phone up, and he kept it steady, and he let it see what it saw.
Sullivan's hand hovered near the phone and then fell back. He seemed to remember, all at once, that there were other people in the lot, and that the second deputy was watching, and that the woman two spaces over was watching, and that the afternoon was no longer a private matter between two men. He dropped his reaching hand to his side, and he told Clarence, in a voice that tried to sound like an order and came out sounding like a request, to keep the phone down and his hands visible. Clarence kept the phone up. He said he would keep his hands visible, and he said the phone would stay visible too, and he said Sullivan was welcome to look into the lens any time he liked, because the lens was looking at him.
A woman in the crowd lifted her own phone higher, and Clarence saw the small screen glint, and he was glad, because his own phone could fail, and a second record was a second shelter.
A cart rattled past again, and a child laughed somewhere near the store doors, and the ordinary world went on around the small circle of stillness where the two men stood. Clarence felt the sun on the back of his neck, and the phone warm in his hand, and the weight of the afternoon settling into his shoulders. He was seventy two years old, and he was tired, and his groceries were in the trunk, and his house was waiting, and none of that mattered as much as the small red light on the screen. He spoke into the phone once, softly, giving the time and the place and his name, the way a man leaves a marker on a trail, so that anyone who watched later would know where the afternoon had begun. Then he fell silent, and he kept filming, and he waited to see what the deputy would do next, with the whole lot watching, and the record running, and the truth, at last, with a witness that could not be argued with.