THE FINGER IN HIS FACE: THE MEIJER LOT, THE HANDCUFFS, AND THE ID THE DEPUTY WOULD NOT READ

Chapter 26

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The body camera footage arrived at the sheriff's office in a sealed envelope, carried by hand from the evidence room to the desk of Sheriff Donna Fields. She did not open it alone. She asked the investigator to sit with her, and she asked that the door be closed, and she asked that no one speak while the footage played. The investigator was a careful man who wrote slowly and checked his notes twice, and Fields trusted him to see what was there and not to add what was not. The room was small and plain, with a desk, two chairs, and a screen, and the light from the window fell across the floor in a long bar.

Fields pressed play, and the lot appeared, bright and ordinary. The camera moved with Sullivan's steps, and the silver Lexus came into view, and Clarence Webb stood beside it with his keys in one hand and his papers in the other. The sound was clear. Sullivan's voice came first, sharp and fast, telling Clarence to step away from the car. Clarence answered in a steady voice, saying the car was his, saying the papers in his hand would prove it. The investigator wrote the time in his notebook, and then he wrote the words, as close as he could, in the plain style he always used.

The finger came next. The camera showed Sullivan's hand reaching out, the finger extended, close to Clarence's face. Clarence did not step back. He held his ground and held out the license and the registration, and he asked Sullivan to read them. The camera caught the papers clearly, white against the dark of Clarence's jacket, and it caught Sullivan's hand pushing them aside. Fields paused the footage there, and the still image held on the screen: the papers, the hand, and the face of a man of seventy two asking to be heard. She looked at the investigator, and he nodded, and he wrote down what the still image showed, in words that left no room for argument.

When the footage played again, the refusal was plain. Sullivan told Clarence to put the papers down. Clarence asked a third time for Sullivan to read them, and his voice stayed steady, and the camera recorded every word. Sullivan took the handcuffs from his belt, and the metal caught the light, and Clarence lifted his phone with his other hand and said he was recording. The investigator wrote that down too, and he wrote the time, and he wrote that Sullivan told Clarence to stop filming, and that Clarence did not stop. The footage showed the cuffs going on beside the car, and the groceries in the open trunk, and the crowd gathering at a distance, and Irene Duarte with her phone held steady.

Harper appeared in the frame behind Sullivan, standing a few steps back, saying nothing. The camera caught him once, looking at Clarence, and then looking away, and then looking at the ground. Fields paused the footage again and asked the investigator to note the position of Harper, and the distance, and the fact that he did not speak and did not step forward. The investigator wrote it down, and he wrote that Harper's silence was visible, and that it was part of the record, and that it would matter later when Harper gave his own account. Fields did not comment.

The rest of the footage ran without a pause. Steve Ball came out of the store and asked what was happening, and Sullivan told him to step back. Clarence asked to call his son, and Sullivan said no calls. The camera showed Clarence's hands, cuffed in front of him, and it showed his face, calm and tired, and it showed the long minutes passing while the lot waited. When Fields herself arrived in the footage, the camera turned, and her voice came through, even and firm, asking Sullivan to step aside, and the footage ended with the cuffs coming off and Clarence rubbing his wrists.

Fields sat back in her chair when the screen went dark. The investigator closed his notebook, and for a moment neither of them spoke. Then Fields asked him to write a summary of what the footage showed, in order, without opinion, and to mark the times where the refusal happened and where the cuffing happened, and to keep the summary with the footage itself. He agreed, and he began to write.

The investigator finished his summary and read it back to her, slowly, and she listened to every word, and she asked him to change one sentence that went further than the footage went, and he changed it, and she signed the summary at the bottom, and he signed it too. The envelope was sealed again, and it was logged, and it was carried back to the evidence room, and the door of the small room was opened, and the ordinary sounds of the office came back in. Fields kept a copy of the summary on her desk, and she put it in the file with the dispatch audio and the store camera footage, and the file grew thicker, and the facts grew clearer, and the review moved on to the statements, where the words of men would be measured against what the camera had already shown. The camera had done its work, and the review would do the rest.

Chapter Twenty Seven

The Statement That Matched

News in the same category

THE FINGER IN HIS FACE: THE MEIJER LOT, THE HANDCUFFS, AND THE ID THE DEPUTY WOULD NOT READ

45 Part