Sheriff Donna Fields arrived at her office early the next morning, before the phones began to ring, and she went straight to her desk and opened a fresh file. She wrote Clarence Webb's name on the tab, and the date, and the place, the Meijer store parking lot, and she set the file in the center of her desk where she could see it all day. She had promised Clarence at the lot that there would be a review, and she meant to keep that promise in the open, with a record that anyone could follow, step by step, from the first call to the last finding. She called in a senior deputy, by role only, and she told him she wanted the review kept separate from the regular chain of command, and that he would report to her directly, and that no one who had been in the lot that afternoon would touch the file except through her. The senior deputy nodded and took notes, and Fields gave him his first three tasks, to request the dispatch audio, to collect every piece of footage, and to take written statements from everyone who had been named at the lot, and to bring her everything untouched and in order.
The first request went out before nine in the morning. Fields signed a form asking for the full dispatch audio for the afternoon, from the first report of the stolen car to the last message sent to the deputies in the lot, and she marked it urgent, and she asked that the original recording be copied without editing, and that the copy be logged with the time it was made. She signed a second form asking for the store camera footage from the Meijer store, for the whole afternoon, from the camera that looked over the lot, and she asked that it be copied in full, without cuts, and logged the same way. She signed a third form ordering that Deputy Mark Sullivan's body camera footage be preserved untouched, and that no one view it except the investigator and herself until the review was complete, and that the camera itself be stored and sealed. She signed each form slowly, and she checked each one twice, because she knew that a review lives or dies on the care taken with the record at the very start, and that a single missing minute could undo months of good work.
By midmorning the investigator had begun his calls. He spoke to the dispatcher, by role only, and he asked for the audio log and the written log of the calls, and he was told they would be ready by the end of the day. He spoke to Steve Ball, the store manager, and he asked for the store camera footage and the receipt of Clarence's shopping, and Steve Ball said both were ready and waiting, and that he had kept them himself, and that no one else had touched them. He spoke to Irene Duarte, and he asked for her video, and she said she had already given a copy to the sheriff at the lot, and that she had kept her own copy safe at home, and that she would bring it in if it was needed. He spoke to Deputy Luke Harper, and he asked for a written statement, and Harper said he would write it that day, in full, and that he would sign it, and that he would not leave anything out.
Fields spent the afternoon reading the statements she already had, the short ones taken at the lot, and she made notes in the margin of each, questions to ask, details to check, times to confirm. She wrote down the times as Clarence remembered them, about 2:10 when he was about to drive home, about 2:20 when the cuffs went on, about 2:45 when she herself had arrived, and she marked each one as approximate, to be checked against the footage and the audio. She wrote down the names of the people who had been present, Clarence, Sullivan, Harper, Irene, Steve Ball, and the crowd, and she wrote down what each one had said, in short plain lines. She did not write down any conclusion, and she did not allow herself to form one yet, because a review that begins with the ending already written is not a review at all, and she had promised Clarence something better than that. At the end of the day she closed the file and locked it in her desk, and she went home tired and satisfied that the work had begun properly, with the record first, and the judgment later, and the promise kept in the order she had said it would be kept.
The next morning Fields called Clarence at home and told him the review had begun, the dispatch audio and the footage had been requested, and the file was locked in her desk. Clarence thanked her and said he would wait for whatever she found. Fields said she would call again when there was something solid to report. Clarence put the phone down and told Anthony, and Anthony wrote the date of the call in his notebook. Clarence went back to his coffee, and the morning felt a little lighter, not because anything had been decided, but because the work was moving in the open, and he would be told what it found, in its own time, and that was enough for now.
Chapter Twenty Four
The Dispatch Audio