THE FINGER IN HIS FACE: THE MEIJER LOT, THE HANDCUFFS, AND THE ID THE DEPUTY WOULD NOT READ

Chapter 28

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Mark Sullivan came to the sheriff's office two days after Harper, and he came with a lawyer's card in his pocket and a careful look on his face that he had practiced in the mirror. He was twenty nine, and he had been a deputy for five years, and he had always been proud of acting fast, and he had told himself that speed was the same as courage. Sheriff Donna Fields met him in the same small room, and she set the same clean pad of paper on the desk, and the same pen, and she told him the same words she had told Harper: take his time, write what he remembered, in order, and do not worry about how it would read. She left him alone, and she closed the door, and she did not stand outside it listening. The account had to be his own, and the review would measure it against the footage either way.

Sullivan sat and looked at the blank paper for a long time. He thought about the dispatch call, and the stolen silver Lexus, and the plate as it had been read out. He thought about Clarence Webb beside the car, and the keys, and the papers, and the phone, and the crowd, and the way the afternoon had slipped out of his hands the moment the sheriff arrived and read the plate herself. He picked up the pen, and he began to write, and his hand moved quickly at first, and then more slowly, as the memory of the footage caught up with the memory of the afternoon. He wrote that he had believed the report, and that he had acted fast, and that he had not read the papers. He wrote that he had been sure the man was stalling, and that the papers were a delay, and that the cuffs were the safe choice. He did not write that he had pushed the papers aside. He did not write that Clarence had asked three times. He wrote that the papers had been offered, and that he had told Clarence to put them down, and he left it there, as if the telling of it that way made it smaller.

When he finished, he read the account through once, and he changed nothing, and he signed his name, and he wrote the date and the time, and he carried the pad out to Fields. She read it at her desk while he stood waiting, and she read it a second time, and then she laid it beside the summary of the body camera footage, and she compared them line by line, the way she had compared Harper's statement. The dispatch call was there. The stolen car report was there. The cuffing was there. But the refusal was not there in the same words. Sullivan had written that the papers were offered and put down. The footage showed the papers pushed aside, and three requests to read them, and a refusal spoken plainly. The difference was not large in words, and it was everything in meaning, and Fields marked it with her pen, and she wrote a note in the margin, and she dated the note.

She told him plainly that his account did not match the footage on the refusal, which showed him pushing the papers aside and refusing three requests. She said she was not accusing him of lying, and that the record was what the review would stand on. Sullivan listened, and his face went red, and he said that he had acted on the report, and that he had believed it, and that he had not meant to wrong anyone. Fields listened, and she nodded, and she said that belief was not the question, and that the question was the papers in the man's hand, and that a deputy who would not read papers would not hear the truth when it was offered to him.

Sullivan asked what would happen next, and Fields told him that the review would finish, and that he would be suspended, and that he would be retrained, and that no criminal charge would be brought against him, because the review had found a failure of procedure and judgment, and not a crime. She said the words plainly, and she watched his face as she said them, and she saw relief and shame together, and she did not soften the words to make either one easier. She told him to go home and wait for the written findings, and to say nothing about the review until it was done. He left with the lawyer's card still in his pocket, unused, and the door closed behind him, and the small room was quiet again.

Fields kept his account in the file, beside Harper's statement and the footage summary, and the file told the story from one more direction, and the direction did not change the facts. She wrote her own note about the comparison, in her own hand, and she signed it, and she put it with the rest. The note said that Sullivan's account matched the footage on the report and the cuffing, and differed on the refusal, and that the footage governed. She read the note once more before she filed it, and she thought about how a man could believe he had done his job and still have failed the man in front of him, and how the review had to act on the facts, and not on the feelings, of either man.

Chapter Twenty Nine

The Son's File

News in the same category

THE FINGER IN HIS FACE: THE MEIJER LOT, THE HANDCUFFS, AND THE ID THE DEPUTY WOULD NOT READ

45 Part