THE FINGER IN HIS FACE: THE MEIJER LOT, THE HANDCUFFS, AND THE ID THE DEPUTY WOULD NOT READ

Chapter 31

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Chapter Thirty One

The New Rule

Donna Fields wrote the new rule herself, at her own desk, on a plain sheet of paper, with a pen that did not skip. She wrote it in short sentences, because she wanted no deputy to need a second reading to understand it. She wrote that before any stop on a reported stolen car, the plate must be read back digit by digit. She wrote that the deputy who read the plate must say each digit aloud, one at a time, and that the dispatcher must repeat each digit back, one at a time, and that the two readings must match before the deputy moved. She wrote that the registration in the driver's hand must be read before any cuffs were touched. When she had finished, she read the page twice, changed one word, and read it again. Then she signed her name at the bottom and wrote the date beside it, in the same plain hand.

She called the deputies together in the room where they gathered before a shift. Luke Harper stood near the back, his hands at his sides, his face quiet. The other deputies stood in a loose row, some with coffee, some without, all of them listening. Fields read the rule aloud, slowly, from the first word to the last, and she did not hurry any sentence. She said the rule had come from the afternoon in the Meijer lot, and she said she would not dress that fact in softer words. She said a plate had been read wrong by one digit, and she said a man had been cuffed beside his own car because no one had read the plate back and no one had read the papers in his hand. She said the rule was not a punishment. She said it was a guardrail, put in place so that no deputy would have to stand where Mark Sullivan had stood, and so that no driver would have to stand where Clarence Webb had stood. She said she expected every deputy in the room to follow it on every stop, on a quiet day and on a busy one, when the radio was calm and when it was not.

When she had finished reading, she asked if there were questions. One deputy asked whether the read back would slow a stop when a car was moving away. Fields said it would slow the stop by less than a minute, and that a minute spent on a correct plate was better than an afternoon spent on a wrong one. Harper said nothing during the questions, but he nodded once when Fields looked his way, and Fields nodded back.

After the meeting, Fields pinned the rule to the board beside the dispatch desk, where every deputy would see it at the start of a shift. She pinned a second copy to the board in the room where reports were written. She asked the dispatcher on duty to read the rule once, aloud. The dispatcher read it, slowly, and said the words back without stumbling. Fields thanked her, and she wrote a note in the file that the rule had been issued, read aloud, and posted.

That afternoon, a deputy on patrol stopped a car whose plate had been reported, and the radio traffic told the story of the new rule in real time. The deputy read the plate digit by digit. The dispatcher repeated each digit back. The readings matched, and the stop went forward as it should, with papers read and questions asked in order. On another call, the readings did not match, and the deputy waited, and the second reading showed a digit out of place, and the deputy let the car go with a wave. Fields heard both calls from her office, and she wrote both outcomes in the file, because a rule is only words until it is used, and she wanted the file to show the rule working on ordinary calls, not only on the call that had made it necessary.

In the evening, Fields sat at her desk and thought about the rule as a thing that would outlast the afternoon that had made it necessary. Rules written in anger did not hold, she knew, because anger faded and the words went with it. Rules written in plain language, from a plain account of what had gone wrong, held longer. She thought about Clarence Webb standing beside his car with his papers held out, and she was glad the rule did not mention the finger or the cuffs by name. It mentioned only the plate, and the read back, and the papers, and that was enough. A rule that named a man would feel like blame. A rule that named a practice would feel like guidance, and guidance was what she wanted to leave behind. Before she left for the night, she walked past the board beside the dispatch desk and read the rule once more. The paper was straight, the pins were firm, and the words were plain. She did not think the rule would end every mistake. She thought it would catch the kind of mistake that had been made in the lot, the small mistake of one digit, made in haste, and left unchecked. That was enough for one rule, and enough for one day. The rest of the work would come in the training room, and in the meeting that was still to come, one careful step at a time.

News in the same category

THE FINGER IN HIS FACE: THE MEIJER LOT, THE HANDCUFFS, AND THE ID THE DEPUTY WOULD NOT READ

45 Part