Chapter Eighteen
The Statements at the Lot
Fields took her notebook in hand and began with Clarence, because Clarence was the man the afternoon had happened to, and his account had to come first. She asked him to tell it in order, from the time he came out of the store, and she wrote as he spoke, and she stopped him now and then to ask a question, and to make sure she had a time right, or a word right, and Clarence answered plainly, the way he had answered his students' parents for thirty years, with facts first and feelings kept where they belonged.
He told her about the groceries, and the cart, and the keys in his hand. He told her about Sullivan approaching, and the order to step away from the car, and the claim that the car was reported stolen. He told her about the finger in his face, and the papers held out, and the refusal, asked three times, and the handcuffs, and the phone in his other hand, filming, because Dorothy had once told him, after a hard meeting with a parent, that a record kept an honest man safe. He told her about Harper standing silent, and about Irene filming, and about the crowd, and about asking to call his son, and being told no calls. He did not raise his voice. He did not add anything that had not happened. When he finished, Fields read the statement back to him, and he nodded, and he signed his name at the bottom of the page, in the careful hand he used for school records.
"Thank you, Mr. Webb," Fields said. "You have been clear, and I am grateful for it."
She turned to Harper next, and Harper stood straight, and he gave his statement without hesitation, and his account matched Clarence's in every detail that mattered. He said he had arrived with Sullivan, and he had stood behind him, and he had said nothing, and he was sorry for the silence now. He said he had seen the papers held out, and he had seen Sullivan refuse them, and he had seen the finger pointing, and the cuffing, and he had done nothing to stop it. Fields wrote it all down, and when Harper finished, she thanked him, and she told him his honesty would be noted.
Irene Duarte came next, and she was brief and exact. She said she had been three spaces away, loading her own groceries, when she heard raised voices, and she had taken out her phone, and she had filmed from the first word to the last. She said the older man had been calm, and the deputy had been loud, and the papers had been held out more than once, and refused. Fields asked her for the video, and Irene sent it to the number Fields gave her, right there in the lot, and Fields watched the first minute of it on her own phone, and nodded, and wrote down the time the video began and the time it ended.
Steve Ball came last of the four, and he spoke like a man who runs a store and is used to telling the truth in plain terms. He said Clarence was a regular customer, known by name to the staff, and that he had come out when a clerk told him there was trouble in the lot. He said he had asked Sullivan what was happening, and Sullivan had told him to step back, and he had stepped back, but he had watched from the doors. He said he had seen the cuffing, and he had seen the crowd, and he had brought the store camera footage on a drive, and he gave the drive to Fields, and Fields thanked him, and wrote down his name and his job, and the time the store camera covered.
Fields stood then, with four statements in her notebook, and a video on her phone, and a drive in her hand, and she spoke to the people still standing there, briefly, so that they would know the afternoon was being handled, and not left to rumor.
"I have taken statements from Mr. Webb, from Deputy Harper, from Ms. Duarte, and from Mr. Ball," she said. "I have Ms. Duarte's video, and the store camera footage, and I will have the body camera footage as well. No one is being charged here today. Mr. Webb is free to go, and I will see this matter through myself."
The crowd began to break up then, slowly, and shoppers went back to their carts, and their cars, and their afternoons, and a few of them stopped to shake Clarence's hand, and he thanked them, quietly, and he did not linger, because he wanted to go home, and he wanted the groceries put away, and he wanted the afternoon to end in his own kitchen.
Fields walked with Clarence to his car, and she opened the door for him, and she said she would call him the next day, and that he should keep his papers and his phone and his receipt, and that nothing about the afternoon would be decided without the record being read first. Clarence thanked her, and he sat down in the driver's seat, and Anthony stood beside the car, and the engine turned over, smooth and familiar, and the lot fell away behind them as they drove toward the exit.
Chapter Nineteen
The Body Camera Preserved