THE FINGER IN HIS FACE: THE MEIJER LOT, THE HANDCUFFS, AND THE ID THE DEPUTY WOULD NOT READ

Chapter 37

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Sheriff Donna Fields stood up from her chair at the front of the room and walked to the table where Clarence had just spoken. She did not hurry, and she did not raise her voice. She thanked Clarence by name, and she thanked the room for coming, and she said she would state the findings of the review plainly, and then she would answer questions, and that she would answer them for as long as people had them. She set a thin folder on the table and opened it. The room settled.

She began with the dispatch audio. She said the recording had been pulled and listened to twice, and that it showed the plate read out with one digit transposed, and that no read back had been made. She said a single wrong digit had put a deputy in front of the wrong car and the wrong man, and that the office owned the error.

She went on to the footage. She said the body camera had been preserved untouched, on her order, the same afternoon, and that it showed the deputy refusing the papers Clarence held out, and showed the finger pointing, and showed the cuffing beside the car. She said the store camera had shown the same afternoon from above, without sound, and that the video taken by the bystander had shown it from a few spaces away, steady and complete. She said the second deputy's written statement matched the footage in every detail, and that she had commended him for it, and cleared him. She said the facts were these: the wrong car, the wrong man, the papers refused, the cuffs applied, and then the plate read correctly, and the man released at the lot, with no charge brought against him.

She paused and looked out at the room. She said the deputy who had made the stop had been suspended for thirty days, and had been assigned retraining on stops, on papers, and on read backs. She said no criminal charge had been brought against him, and that the review had found a failure of procedure and of patience, and not a crime. She did not name him beyond his role, and she did not invite the room to judge the man apart from the act. She said he had sat in training and watched his own body camera footage, and had written what he should have done differently, and that the paper belonged to the training file.

Then she stated the new rule. She said it in plain words, slowly, so that everyone in the room could carry it home. A reported plate must be read back, digit by digit, before a stop on a reported stolen car. No exceptions for a busy afternoon, and no exceptions for a sure feeling. The plate would be read, and read back, and checked against the car in front of the deputy, before any order was given and before any cuff was touched. The rule had been posted in the office, she said, and it would be taught to every deputy, and it would be checked in every review. She said the office would use the rule, and answer for it if it was not used.

She opened the floor to questions. A woman in the second row asked whether the deputy would patrol again, and Fields said he would return to supervised duty, riding with a senior deputy, and following the read back rule on every stop, and that his work would be watched. A man near the back asked about the footage, and Fields said it was in the file, and that the record was the point. A young woman asked what a resident should do if papers are refused, and Fields said to keep a steady voice, to ask plainly that the papers be read, to film if it was safe to do so, and to call the office afterward, and that the call would be answered, and the complaint taken down. A woman in the third row asked whether the new rule would be taught to new deputies as well as old ones, and Fields said it would be taught to every deputy, new and old, and tested in training, and checked in every review.

An older man asked whether Clarence had been offered anything, money or otherwise, and Fields said no settlement had been made, and that Clarence had asked for none, and that what he had asked for was the rule, and the record, and the truth told in the open, and that the office had given him those things. A woman asked whether the dispatcher had been disciplined, and Fields said the dispatch process had been changed, and that the read back rule applied to dispatch as well, and that the person at the desk was addressed by role in the review, and that the fix was in the procedure, not in blame alone.

Clarence sat in the front row through all of it, his hands folded, listening. He did not speak again, and he did not need to. When the questions slowed, Fields closed the folder and thanked the room, and said the meeting was over, and that anyone with more to say could stay and say it to her, or write it down and leave it at the desk. People rose slowly, and Clarence shook hands at the door, and Anthony drove him home through the quiet streets.

Chapter Thirty Eight

The Quiet After

News in the same category

THE FINGER IN HIS FACE: THE MEIJER LOT, THE HANDCUFFS, AND THE ID THE DEPUTY WOULD NOT READ

45 Part