The meeting room at the sheriff's office was not large, and by the time Clarence Webb arrived it was nearly full. Folding chairs had been set out in rows, and people sat shoulder to shoulder, neighbors and strangers, and a few young deputies standing along the back wall. A table stood at the front, and behind it a clock ticked loud enough to hear when the room went quiet. Clarence wore his dark jacket, the one he had worn to Dorothy's memorial service, and in the inside pocket he carried the folded pages of his speech. Anthony walked beside him, a hand light on his father's elbow, and steered him to a chair in the front row. Clarence sat down slowly, feeling the weight of the room settle on him, and he looked at the clock, and he waited.
Sheriff Donna Fields stood at the front and welcomed everyone in a steady voice. She said the meeting had been called so that the facts of one afternoon could be stated plainly, and so that questions could be asked and answered in the open. She said she would speak after him. Then she sat down, and the room turned its faces toward Clarence, and the clock ticked, and Clarence rose from his chair.
He walked to the table without hurrying. He set his pages down and smoothed them with one hand. He looked out at the rows of faces, and he did not rush. When he spoke, his voice was low and even, and it carried to the back of the room without strain, because the room was listening hard.
He began with the morning. He said he had made a list on the fridge, and had driven to the store in his own car, a silver sedan he had bought new eight years before, and had shopped slowly, and paid, and loaded his groceries into the trunk. He said he had stood by his car with his keys in his hand, and that a deputy had come across the lot and told him the car was reported stolen. He said he had answered that the car was his, and that he had held out his license and his registration, and that the deputy had not read them.
He said the deputy had pointed a finger in his face, and that Clarence had kept his own voice steady. He said he had asked the deputy three times to read the papers, and that the deputy had told him to put them down, and had taken the handcuffs from his belt. He said Dorothy had taught him long ago that a steady voice is a kind of shelter, and that he had held to that lesson all afternoon, even with the finger in his face and the cuffs on his wrists. He said he had lifted his phone in his other hand and begun to film, and that he had said plainly that he was recording, and that the deputy had told him to stop.
He said the cuffs had closed around his wrists beside his own car, at about twenty minutes past two, and that a woman with a phone had filmed it from a few spaces away, and that he had asked to call his son, and had been told no.
He said the sheriff had arrived at about a quarter to three, and had walked past the deputy, and had read the plate herself, digit by digit, and had compared it with the registration in his hand. He said one digit in the report had been transposed, read wrong at dispatch, and that the plate on his car was his own, and had always been his own. He said the sheriff had ordered the cuffs removed, and that a second deputy had taken them off, and that he had thanked her quietly, and that she had taken statements at the lot, and that he had gone home with his son that evening.
He looked down at his pages, then folded them again and set them aside. He said he had not come to the meeting to ask for anger, and he had not come to ask for pity. He said he had been a school principal for thirty years, and had learned that a mistake is not the worst thing a person can do. The worst thing, he said, is to refuse to look at the paper that would correct the mistake. He said he had held out the paper, and that it had not been read, and that everything that followed had followed from that. He said he did not speak in anger.
He said what he wanted was simple, and he said it slowly so that it would be remembered. He wanted the plate read back, digit by digit, before any stop of that kind. He wanted the papers read when a man holds them out. He wanted the camera kept, and the record kept, and the truth told in the open, the way it was being told that night. He said he measured a day by whether he could go home and sleep in peace. He said he had slept poorly since that afternoon, and hoped speaking plainly would help.
When he finished, he sat down, and the room stayed silent for a long beat. Anthony put a hand on his father's shoulder, and Sheriff Fields rose and thanked him, and Clarence sat with his hands folded, listening.
Chapter Thirty Seven
The Sheriff Speaks After