Chapter Seven
The ID He Would Not Read
Sullivan looked at the papers the way a man looks at something he has already decided not to see. His eyes flicked down toward Clarence's outstretched hand and then away again, as if the license and the registration were a trick of the light, and his mouth set in a line that Clarence recognized from thirty years of school corridors. It was the look of a young man who had made up his mind and was now protecting the decision from evidence. Clarence kept his hand out. He had held papers out to angry parents and frightened boys and tired teachers, and he knew that a steady hand said more than a loud voice. He kept his hand steady, and he kept his voice steady with it, and he asked Sullivan to read the name on the license, just the name, nothing more.
Sullivan said to put the papers down. He said it once, flatly, and then again, louder, and he took a step closer, and his shadow fell across Clarence's hand. Clarence did not put the papers down. He said, respectfully, that the papers were the whole matter, and that reading them would settle it in less than a minute, and that he would be glad to stand there as long as it took while the deputy read. He said he was not going anywhere, and the car was not going anywhere, and the lot was full of people who could see exactly what was happening. He said it without threat, because it was not a threat. It was a fact, offered plainly, the way he had offered facts all his working life.
The deputy's hand went to his belt. Clarence watched it go, and he watched what came back with it, and he felt the afternoon change its shape around him. Sullivan held the handcuffs in his right hand now, and the metal caught the sun, and the sound they made as they swung was small and ordinary and terrible all at once. Clarence had never been handcuffed in his life. He had shaken hands with governors and comforted children and buried his wife, and he had never once stood in a parking lot with a young man's handcuffs swinging in the light. He looked at the cuffs, and then he looked back at Sullivan's face, and he asked a third time, calmly and clearly, for Sullivan to read the papers before anything else happened.
Sullivan said the papers would be read later. He said Clarence would put them down now, on the roof of the car, and step back, and keep his hands where Sullivan could see them. Clarence heard the order and weighed it. Putting the papers down felt like giving up the one proof he had, and he did not want to give it up. But holding them out had not worked either, and a man of seventy two standing in the sun had to choose between the proof in his hand and the peace of the moment. He chose a middle way, the way Dorothy had taught him, which was to obey the shape of the order while keeping the substance of the truth. He laid the license and the registration on the roof of the car, where they lay in the light, and he stepped back one pace, and he kept his hands open at his sides.
Sullivan glanced at the papers on the roof and then away, and Clarence felt a small, cold disappointment settle in his chest. The papers were there, in plain sight, with his name and the plate and the car described in ordinary print, and the young man would not read them. Clarence thought about the eight years he had driven that car, to the store and to church and to his wife's grave, and about the morning he had signed the papers in the dealer's office, Dorothy beside him, laughing at his care with the pen.
The second deputy shifted his weight near the patrol car and still said nothing. Clarence did not look at him. He kept his eyes on Sullivan, who was turning the handcuffs over in his hand, and he kept his breathing slow, and he thought about what Dorothy would have said if she had been standing there. She would have said to be patient, and to be plain, and to let the truth do its own work in its own time. Clarence had tried patience. He had tried plainness. The truth had not yet had its turn, but he believed it would, because he had seen truth wait out louder men than this one, in hallways and offices, again and again, across forty years.
Sullivan took another step closer, and the handcuffs swung again, and he told Clarence to turn around and put his hands behind his back. Clarence did not turn around. Not yet. He said, once more, that his name was Clarence Webb, and that the car was his, and that the papers on the roof said so, and he asked Sullivan, as one man to another, to read a single line before the cuffs went on. He asked it without anger and without pleading, the way he had asked for things all his life, plainly, as if the asking itself were a kind of dignity. Sullivan's jaw tightened. The handcuffs rose a little higher. The lot held its breath around them, and the papers lay on the roof in the sun, unread, waiting for a reader who would not come.