THE FINGER IN HIS FACE: THE MEIJER LOT, THE HANDCUFFS, AND THE ID THE DEPUTY WOULD NOT READ

Chapter 24

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The dispatch audio arrived at the sheriff's office two days later, on a plain disc in a sealed envelope, with a log sheet signed by the dispatcher, by role only, and a note that the copy was complete and unedited. The investigator signed for it and carried it to the review room, and he played it once through, alone, with the log sheet open beside him, and he wrote down what he heard in short plain lines, the way Fields had asked him to do. The first call was the report of the stolen silver Lexus, read out in a calm voice, with the plate given digit by digit, and the investigator wrote down each digit as he heard it, and he marked the time. The second message was the dispatch to the deputies, sending them to the Meijer store lot, and the plate was read out again, and the investigator wrote it down again, and he stopped the recording, and he played that part a second time, and then a third time, because something in it did not match what he had written down the first time. One digit was different. One digit had been transposed, two numbers swapped in the reading, so that the plate the deputies were given was not the plate of the stolen car, and it was not the plate of Clarence's car either, but a third plate that belonged to no car at all, and yet it was close enough to Clarence's plate that a deputy in a hurry could mistake one for the other.

The investigator played the whole recording again from the start, and he listened for the read back. In a proper dispatch, the deputy who takes the call reads the plate back, digit by digit, and the dispatcher confirms it, and the two readings are checked against each other before anyone moves. In this recording there was no read back. The dispatch was read out once, and Sullivan answered with a short acknowledgment, and that was all. No one repeated the plate. No one checked it. No one caught the transposed digit. The investigator wrote that down too, in plain words, that the audio showed the transposed digit, and that it showed no read back, and he underlined both lines, and he put his initials beside them, and he set the log sheet on top of the disc in the file. He felt a quiet anger as he worked, not at any one person, but at the smallness of the error, at the way a single swapped digit, unheard and unchecked, had traveled from a quiet room to a bright parking lot and had ended with handcuffs on a seventy two year old man beside his own car.

Fields listened to the audio herself that afternoon, with the investigator sitting across from her, saying nothing. She listened to the report, and to the dispatch, and to the silence where the read back should have been, and she listened to it a second time, and she nodded slowly, and she asked the investigator to write a short summary for the file, in words a stranger could follow, with no jargon and no blame, only the facts in order. The summary said that the plate had been read out with one digit transposed, and that no read back had taken place, and that the deputy had therefore approached the wrong car, and that the error had not been caught before the stop. Fields read the summary twice, and she signed it, and she put it in the file beside the disc and the log sheet, and she said, quietly, that this was the center of the whole matter, and that everything else in the review would be measured against it. She thought about Clarence standing in the lot with his papers in his hand, asking to be read, and about the deputy who would not read them, and about how the one error had made the other one possible, and she felt the weight of the office she held, and the duty to make the record plain, so that no other afternoon would turn on a single swapped digit that no one had bothered to check.

The next morning the investigator transcribed the audio word for word, and he laid the transcription beside the written dispatch log, and he compared the two line by line. The written log showed the same transposed digit, written in the dispatcher's hurried hand, and the investigator marked that too, and he wrote a note saying that the error had begun in the reading and had been carried into the writing, and that no second pair of eyes had caught it at either step. He sealed the transcription, the log, and the disc in one envelope and locked it in the review cabinet. Fields read his note that afternoon and she nodded, and she wrote a short line of her own at the bottom of the summary, that the read back gap would be addressed when the review was finished, and that no deputy would ever again be sent to stop a car on a plate that had not been read back and confirmed. She did not write the new rule yet, but she kept the line in the file as a promise to herself, that the silence on the audio, the silence where the read back should have been, would be answered with a rule that left no room for silence at all.

Chapter Twenty Five

News in the same category

THE FINGER IN HIS FACE: THE MEIJER LOT, THE HANDCUFFS, AND THE ID THE DEPUTY WOULD NOT READ

45 Part