THE FINGER IN HIS FACE: THE MEIJER LOT, THE HANDCUFFS, AND THE ID THE DEPUTY WOULD NOT READ

Chapter 40

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Chapter Forty

The Plate Audit

A month after the new rule was posted, Sheriff Donna Fields asked for an audit. She called the clerk who kept the dispatch logs into her office, and she asked for a month of reported plates, every call about a reported stolen car, and every stop that had followed from those calls. She said she wanted to know whether the read back rule was being used, and whether it was catching anything, and that she wanted the answer in numbers and in writing, so that it could be kept in the file with the rest of the record. The clerk nodded, and went back to the log room, and began to pull the reports, one by one, and to lay them out in order.

The audit took three days. The clerk worked through the month methodically, matching each dispatch call to its report, and each report to the plate as it had been read, and to the plate as it had been read back, and to the car that had actually been found. Most of the month was clean. The plates matched, the read backs were noted, the stops were proper, and the cars were the cars in the reports. The clerk marked each one with a check, and set it aside, and went on to the next. It was slow work, and it was the kind of work that rarely gets thanked, and the clerk did it carefully, because the sheriff had asked for it to be done carefully, and because the file would be read by people who had not been in the room.

On the second day, the clerk found the first one. A plate had been read out with two digits transposed, a simple slip of the tongue at dispatch, the kind of slip that happens when a person is reading fast. The read back had caught it. The deputy on the call had read the plate back, digit by digit, and the dispatcher had heard the difference, and had corrected it on the air, and the stop had never been made on the wrong car. The clerk marked it, and wrote a short note beside it, and set it in a separate pile. On the third day, the clerk found the second. Another plate, another transposition, another read back, another correction, another stop that never happened. Two more wrong cars that were never approached, two more drivers who never saw a finger in their faces, two more afternoons that stayed ordinary.

The clerk brought the audit to the sheriff's office on a Friday morning, in a folder with the month's reports behind it, and the two catches marked with paper clips. Fields read it at her desk, slowly, and she read the two notes twice, and she sat back in her chair, and she was quiet for a moment. Then she thanked the clerk, and she signed the audit, and she put it in the file with the dispatch audio, and the footage, and the statements, and the new rule, and the record of the meeting. The file was thick by then, and it held together well, and it told a story that could be followed from the first wrong digit to the last corrected one, without gaps, and without guesses.

She thought about Clarence Webb as she closed the folder. She thought about the afternoon in the lot, and the papers he had held out, and the steady voice that had asked three times to have them read, and about the meeting where he had spoken plainly and without anger, and asked for the rule. She thought that the rule had done, in a single month, exactly what he had asked it to do, and that two people she would never meet had gone about their days without ever knowing how close they had come to a different afternoon. That, she decided, was the point of a rule. It worked quietly, and it worked before the harm, and it did not need a meeting, or a speech, or a crowd to prove itself.

She called the senior deputy in, and she told him the audit's result, and she told him to keep the read back on every stop, and to keep teaching it, and he said he would, and that Sullivan was keeping to it, and that the younger deputies were watching and learning. She called the dispatcher in, and she thanked the person at the desk for the corrections, and she said the read back began at dispatch, and that the desk was part of the rule, not apart from it. She wrote a short memo, and she put a copy in the file, and she sent a copy to the training room, so that the two catches could be taught as examples, without names, and without blame, as proof that the rule worked.

That evening, she locked the office and drove home, and she thought about the file on her desk, and about the man who had gone home to his kitchen table, and about the deputy who was learning to slow down, and she felt the particular tiredness of a day in which something had been done right, and done quietly, and filed away. The audit stayed in the file. The rule stayed on the wall. The record stayed complete. And the month went on, one plate at a time, read, and read back, and checked, the way it should have been done from the start.

Chapter Forty One

News in the same category

THE FINGER IN HIS FACE: THE MEIJER LOT, THE HANDCUFFS, AND THE ID THE DEPUTY WOULD NOT READ

45 Part