page being turned.
"Mr. Archer," she said, "did you say they're calling it regularization?"
"That's the word in the letter," Tom said.
She laughed once, without any humor in it at all. "Come in tomorrow," she
said. "Bring the file. Bring all of it — the policy, your survey, the letter you
sent them, the bill, the packet, the tow receipt. If you've got the declaration,
bring that too."
"I have the declaration," Tom said. "I got it from the courthouse when I
bought. I wanted to know what I wasn't joining."
"Bring it," Molly Tran said. "Especially that."
Molly Tran's office was over the hardware store still, up a flight of stairs that
smelled of the fertilizer and seed below. He had brought the file himself, in
the accordion folder he used for field records, and she spread its contents
across her desk in the order he had kept them, which she noticed and
approved with a nod so small he might have imagined it. She was fifty,
perhaps, with her hair cut short for the summer and reading glasses on a cord,
and she read the packet standing up, the way she had read his survey at the
closing, with one finger traveling.
"Sit down, Mr. Archer," she said, without looking up. "This is going to take
the time it takes."
He sat. The window gave onto the square, and the courthouse across it,
where the records lived. He had spent the best years of his life in rooms like
that one, coaxing old deeds out of old indexes, and it steadied him to see the
26
building from where he sat. Molly read the letters, and the bill, and the tow
receipt twice — and the second time she put her finger on his sentence above
the signature and kept it there a moment, the way a surveyor sets a finger on
a corner.
"You wrote this on the receipt," she said.
"I paid under protest," Tom said. "I wanted the record to show it at the time,
not after."
"It does," she said. "It does exactly that. Whoever taught you to paper a
file—"
"Forty years of watching other men's files lose their cases," Tom said.
She sat down then, and took off the glasses, and gave him the law the way
she gave everything, in a plain style, in order, without raising her voice at
any of it.
"Mr. Archer, I want to be careful, because careful is what this is. Annexation
is not a mood. Under the Declaration — the original one, 1987, the only one
anybody has ever shown me or you — Article Twelve says a lot joins this
association when its owner signs a written consent and a supplemental
declaration saying so is recorded. Recorded, Mr. Archer. In that building
across the square. That is the whole mechanism. There isn't another one. The
developer could have annexed the Point lots before he sold them. He didn't.
He went bankrupt in 2009 with the paperwork undone, and after that the only
road in ran through the owners' signatures, one lot at a time. Yours has never
been asked for. Ed Kowalski's has never been asked for."
"I know," Tom said.
"You know. But I want you to hear what it means in my language, because
27
it's stronger in my language. A board vote to annex you anyway isn't an
annexation with a defect in it. It's not a technicality waiting to be cured. It is
a nullity. It has the legal effect of a vote by the Elk Shoals Rotary Club. The
association has no more jurisdiction over your lot than the Rotary does —
less, maybe, the Rotary never towed your truck."
The glasses went back on. She turned the tow work order around to face him,
as she imagined Tyler's counter had.
"Now this. When a body with no jurisdiction over land orders a vehicle taken
off that land, the taking is a conversion. That's not a fine word for a fine
thing; it's the old word, and it means your property was treated as somebody
else's to dispose of. The association ordered it. Hensley Recovery performed
it. In the eyes of the law they share it, the way two men share a ladder. The
tow fee, the storage, the transmission — and we'll get the transmission
documented, Mr. Archer, by a mechanic, in writing, before it gets worse or
better — all of that is damages, and it is recoverable, and it is not the largest
thing in this file. The fines are void. A fine is a remedy, and remedies belong
to members. The dues bill is void for the same reason, all twenty-one
hundred and fifty dollars of it, and the seventy-five-dollar records fee I
intend to enjoy asking them about, in a deposition if it comes to that."
She stopped. She turned one more page — the last notice, the review of
privileges — and her voice, when it came back, had something in it that had
not been there for the tow.
"But this is the page I want you to think about. The road. And the lake
access. They can't take your lake access; that's an easement appurtenant,
recorded, runs with your land. The road is a county road. But they run the
gatehouse list, and a threat doesn't have to be lawful to be expensive, and
they know it. And Mr. Archer — I understand from the minutes Ed
28
Kowalski's wife got hold of that this fall the association votes on a marina
bond. Two-thirds of the membership, the Declaration requires, of all lots