member since long before the phases were drawn, and reported back from
the tailgate of his own truck in Tom's driveway, the way the Point Road
supreme court had sat all fall. "Passed," Ed said. "Wasn't close. You know
why it passed, Tommy? Because nobody had to pretend anything to vote for
it. Forty slips. Their own beach. Money on the table where you can see it.
Turns out people like that. Who knew."
"Ninety slips of pretending was a heavier lift," Tom said.
"Ninety slips of pretending sank," Ed said, "under its own weight, in four feet
of water, with everybody watching." He considered. "There's probably a
sermon in that."
"There's sermons in everything, the way you fish."
But the letter that mattered arrived the following Tuesday, and it was not the
vote tally, which the association mailed to members only. It came in a long
envelope, association letterhead, addressed to Thomas Archer, Lot 6, Point
Road — to him by name and lot, not to the Point Road as a weather system
— and it was signed by Greg Nolan, President, and it asked a question.
The association, the letter said, was planning an opening regatta for the
marina in the summer, and six event days a year thereafter, on which the
clubhouse lot and the marina lot together would not hold the cars. The only
flat ground near the clubhouse was Tom's meadow, across the lane from the
clubhouse lot, approximately two acres of it suitable. The association
therefore asked whether the owner of Lot 6 would grant the association a
recorded license for event-day overflow parking on the meadow: for the
regatta and up to six further event days per calendar year, notice to be given
114
fourteen days ahead; vehicles to be directed by association volunteers and
kept to the mowed portion; a fee of two hundred and fifty dollars per event
day; the license to run five years, and to be revocable by either party on sixty
days' written notice; a draft license was enclosed for his review, with a
signature line, and the association's attorney's name and telephone number,
and the letter closed by saying that if the answer was no, the association
would understand and would rent the school lot and run a shuttle, and that
the asking was the point and the answer was his.
Tom read it twice at the mailbox. Then he read it a third time at the kitchen
table, with coffee, the way he read documents that were going to matter, and
what he noticed, reading it as a man reads a survey — for what it actually
said, in order — was that everything in it was the shape of the thing the
association had never once done in the whole history of the phases. It asked.
It named a term. It named a price. It provided for its own ending, in writing,
at either party's hand. It had a signature line, which is the place where
consent lives, and the line was blank, and it was his.
He set it beside the plat of his lot, the two documents lying together on the
oilcloth, the meadow appearing in both of them — in one as a shaded
polygon with a lot number, in the other as a courtesy being requested — and
he thought about the tow truck in his driveway in September, and the word
unauthorized, and the long education of the fall, and he found that he was not
angry, and had not been angry for some time, and that the absence of anger
left his judgment pleasantly unobstructed. The meadow was grass. It could
hold cars six days a year and be grass the other three hundred and fifty-nine.
The question was never the cars. The question had only ever been the asking.
He called the association's attorney, whose name was on the letter, and made
two changes, and he made them in the tone of a man adjusting a fence line:
115
pleasantly, precisely, and without any interest in negotiating further than the
adjustments themselves.
The first was the fee. Two hundred and fifty dollars a day priced the thing as
a rental, and a rental implied a landlord, and Tom had spent a year
establishing that he was not the association's landlord, tenant, member, or
resource. A license, he said, is a permission, and a permission should cost
what consent is worth, and not a cent more: one dollar a year. The attorney
was quiet a moment and said that a nominal consideration was, legally
speaking, perfectly sound — better than sound, it was classical — and Tom
said he was glad the law agreed with him, it made a change from the fall.
The second was the meadow itself. After any event that left ruts — and cars
on wet grass will rut it, and the letter might as well describe the world it
intended rather than the world it hoped for — the association would re-seed
the rutted portion within thirty days, at its own cost, with a mix the county
extension recommended. Papers, Tom said, should describe the world they
intend. He had read a great many papers, in the last year, that described
worlds nobody intended, and they were the expensive kind.
The attorney redrafted. Greg Nolan came out to the house himself on a
Thursday evening to sit at the kitchen table — the president of the
association, in Tom's kitchen, drinking Tom's coffee, which had also never
happened in the history of the phases — and went through the final draft with
a pencil, clause by clause, including the one-dollar fee and the re-seeding and