entitled to vote. If the board counts six Point lots in that denominator — six
lots that are not members and aren't entitled to vote at all — then every
percentage they announce is wrong, and a bond passed on a wrong count is
voidable at the suit of any member who objects. Any member. Not you —
you have no standing in their meeting, which is rather the point of you — but
any one of the four hundred who pays dues and doesn't want a marina on
false arithmetic. That is the association's real exposure here. Not your tow.
Your tow is the symptom that will bring the arithmetic into a courtroom."
She sat back. She took the glasses off again and let them hang.
"So. Paper first, in order, the way you'd run a survey. One: a certified copy of
the register's index for everything touching Phase Three — the plat, the
Declaration, every supplement ever recorded. What is not there is our best
evidence, and I want it certified, so the absence has a seal on it. Two: the
Declaration itself, certified. Three: your title policy and your survey. Four: a
demand letter, my letterhead, with a deadline in it — fourteen days —
withdrawing the bills and the fines, repaying the tow and the storage,
reserving the transmission, and stipulating to the phase boundary as it was
drawn in 1987. No speeches. A demand letter is a survey of what happens
next if nobody moves; it should read like one. And five, which is not paper:
the question I ask every client before I fire the first shot, because the answer
decides what the shots are for. What do you want, Mr. Archer? Not what do
you want them to stop doing. What do you want."
Tom had known the question was coming. He had driven in with it riding
beside him, and he found, saying it, that it came out in the order he had
rehearsed without knowing he was rehearsing.
29
"I want my truck made whole," he said. "The tow, the storage, the
transmission, the crease in the door — whole, the way it was before their
paperwork touched it. I want the bills withdrawn, all of them, and the fines,
and I want it in writing, not over the telephone. I want the marina vote
counted honestly — six lots that aren't members out of the count, and let the
members decide about their marina with true numbers. And I want my lot left
alone. The line where it was drawn in 1987, Molly. That's all. That's the
whole of it."
"You don't want the marina killed."
"I do not. If four hundred people who belong to that association want a
marina and vote for it fair, that's their business and their money. I've got no
more right to reach into their meeting than they've got to reach into my
driveway. That's not a principle I can afford to hold one way."
"You don't want Carol Hensley ruined."
Tom considered this the way he considered a distance that had to be chained
twice. "No," he said. "I don't know what I think Carol is, yet. She's wrong
about the paper. She may just be wrong. Ruining people for being wrong
about paper — the county would be empty by Friday." He paused. "If she
knew, that's another survey. We'll see what the ground shows."
Molly Tran looked at him for a moment with an expression he recognized
from the best engineers and the best registers of deeds: the look of a
professional who has found the file in better order than she expected to, and
the client steadier.
"Paper first," she said. "In order." She was already reaching for a legal pad.
"Fourteen days. And Mr. Archer — the truck. Mechanic. This week. In
writing."
30
The tow had a half-life, the way everything in a subdivision does, and it
decayed at different rates at the mailbox and at the boat ramp. At the
mailbox, the county paper's account — three paragraphs in the local section
— was read with coffee and delivered into conversation pre-digested: the
association had towed a truck, the truck's owner said he wasn't a member, the
association said he was. At the boat ramp, where men had watched Tom
Archer back that Ford down to the water for three summers, the opinions ran
hotter. The truck was an eyesore, said the new houses. The truck was a work
of art, said the old ones, and the new houses said that was easy to claim for a
man who didn't have to look at it from a kitchen window — and there the
argument would run aground, pleasantly, the way it was meant to.
The free-rider question floated above all of it, too large to be settled at a
ramp. The Point lots used the road the association repaved — no, the county
repaved; the association landscaped the entrance and manned the gatehouse
list. The Point owners fished the lake the association stocked — the state
stocked it, on a schedule in the regulations digest. Back and forth it went, a
boundary dispute conducted entirely in amenities, and Tom, who knew
exactly which corporation maintained what, kept the knowledge to himself.
Being right at the mailbox is an expense no one reimburses.
Two of the six Point owners paid their bills.
He learned it from Ed, who learned it from the Harpers' daughter. The
Harpers were on Lot 1, retired down from Ohio, and the wife's sister was
coming for the fall and the road-privileges letter had frightened her in a way
Tom could not bring himself to think small of. A threat doesn't have to be