numbered prose of the title trade. Taxes. The easement for utilities along the
rear line, book and page given. The recorded access easement of 1988, book
and page given, the road over the subdivision's streets that he had driven
home on an hour ago. The covenants and restrictions of the original
development — and here he read slowly, the way a man reads a letter he has
been expecting for years without knowing it — appearing as an exception in
a specific and limited form: the covenants that ran with the land by the plat
itself, the setback lines, the building restrictions, the matters recorded against
the lot in its own right.
And then the list ended. Eleven exceptions. He read it twice, and then a third
time, aloud, under his breath, the way he had read plats as a young man.
There was no homeowners association in it. No declaration of covenants
creating an association over Lot 6, no membership obligation, no dues, no
12
assessment power, no lien. There could not be. A title insurer lists what is of
record against a lot or it does not stay a title insurer, and if Phase Three had
ever been annexed — if any supplemental declaration had ever been
executed and recorded subjecting his lot to the association — it would be
sitting in Schedule B in numbered type, between the taxes and the utility
easement, as plain as a fence post. It was not there because it was not
anywhere, because it had never happened, and a man does not need to take a
surveyor's word for that. He needs only to read the page where it would have
to be.
From the plat cabinet's second drawer he took the 1987 Declaration itself. He
had obtained the copy during his purchase — of course he had; a surveyor
buying land reads the whole chain or he does not buy — and it was full and
clean, forty-one pages, stamped with the recorder's marks of that year. He
found Article XII the way you find a room in a house you have only visited
once, by confidence and one wrong turn. ANNEXATION, it said. The
developer reserved the right to annex additional phases by supplemental
declaration, duly executed and recorded, with this provision, in the flat,
unhurried language of lawyers who expected to be read by strangers in
lamplight decades later: that no lot, once sold and occupied, shall be annexed
to the association without the written consent of its owner, such consent to be
recorded with the supplemental declaration. He read it three times. It did not
require a lawyer to construe. It required only a reader, and readers, he
reflected, were what this sentence had been waiting for since before some of
the people at tonight's meeting were born.
His own memory did the rest, unspooling the year 2009 like a roll of
drawings. He had spent that year at the recorder's counter in Elk Shoals until
the clerks knew his thermos. Title work is a window: through it, a surveyor
13
sees every instrument a county records, in the order it records them, the way
a man at a depot sees every train. A supplemental declaration annexing six
lake lots to a homeowners association is not a subtle instrument. It is a set
piece — execution by the developer, consent forms appended for the
occupied lots, a legal description running pages. It would have come across
that counter, and Tom, who in 2009 was retracing half the subdivisions in the
county for the title company, would have seen it. No such instrument had
come. What had come, that spring and summer, was the bankruptcy — the
petitions, the notices, the trustee's deeds, the long legal unwinding of a
developer who had run out of money and road at the same time — and the
association, leaderless in the matter of Phase Three and busy surviving, had
done what institutions do with unfinished business in a bad year. It had let it
lie. And it had lain there, sixteen years, in a drawer of the county's memory
and a folder in Tom's, until a marina needed widening and a vote needed a
margin and a president with a broker's fluency had reached for the nearest
unfinished thing and called it complete.
He sat a while with the Declaration open and the policy beside it, two
documents in lamplight saying the same quiet thing in two different dialects,
and he felt no triumph in it at all — only something older and heavier, like
the sadness of finding a corner monument disturbed.
He put the tea, cold, aside, and took down a pad of his good paper, the heavy
stock he had ordered by the ream when he retired and used perhaps twice a
year, for letters that were meant to be kept.
The letter took him the better part of an hour, most of it spent not writing. A
surveyor composing a letter of correction proceeds as he proceeds across a
difficult tract: slowly, and with more time spent standing still, looking, than
moving. What he finally set down, in his surveyor's hand — the upright,
14
unhurried capitals and small letters of a man who had lettered plats for forty
years and believed a word should be as legible as a bearing — was short, and
courteous, and entirely without threat, because he was not threatening
anyone. He was correcting the record, which is a different and older
profession.
He identified himself: Thomas Archer, owner of Lot 6, Point Road, retired
licensed land surveyor, Tennessee license number given, forty years in
practice in this county. He stated the matter as he understood it: that at the