annual meeting the association had announced the annexation of the six
Phase Three lots and an intention to bill their owners dues, retroactive one
year. He stated the record as he knew it: that to his knowledge, no
supplemental declaration annexing Phase Three had ever been executed or
recorded; that Article XII of the original Declaration required, for an
occupied lot, the written consent of its owner, recorded; that no consent of
his existed or had ever been given or requested; and that his lot consequently
stood outside the association's jurisdiction — a fact reflected in his owner's
title policy, whose Schedule B, a copy enclosed, listed the covenants of
record against his lot and contained no homeowners association among them.
He asked, in the letter's only request, and it was phrased as a request and not
a demand, that the retroactive billing to the Point Road owners be withdrawn,
and that the announced count for the fall assessment vote be corrected to the
membership as the documents defined it. He closed by saying that he valued
his neighbors and his place among them, that he believed the matter to be an
honest error carried forward from the developer's unfinished business, and
that he was available at the association's convenience to walk anyone through
the records at the courthouse, where they were open to all. He signed it. He
copied it — the letter, the Schedule B — on the machine in the back room.
He put the original and the enclosure in an envelope addressed to the Heron
15
Bay Estates Homeowners Association, attention of its president, and in the
morning he drove it to the post office in Elk Shoals and mailed it certified,
return receipt requested, and when the clerk handed him the green card and
the stamped receipt he took them home and put them in the closing file,
where such things live.
Ed read his copy three days later, on the porch, with the coffee going cold in
a way that had nothing to do with the weather. Ed read the way he did
everything, with his lips moving slightly and one finger holding the place,
and at the end he sat back and looked out at the lake for a while, where a
heron was conducting its own survey of the shallows with an patience Tom
had always admired professionally.
"It's a good letter," Ed said at last. "It's a real good letter, Tom. It's got the
book and page and everything." A pause. "What if they just don't care what
the paper says?"
It was the neighbor's question, and it deserved better than a lawyer's answer,
and Tom considered it with the seriousness of a man who has been asked the
only question that matters. "They'll care or they won't," he said. "That's their
part. The paper's part is to be there when they start caring, and it will be.
Paper is slow, Ed." He turned his mug a quarter-turn on the porch rail, the
way another man might adjust an instrument. "It's not weak. It's just slow."
Ed nodded at the lake as if the lake had said it. "Sixteen years that
annexation's been laying there unfinished," he said. "And Carol picks this fall
to finish it, right when she needs six more votes for her marina. Funny timing
on a formality."
"Formalities are what people call paperwork they haven't read," Tom said.
He said it without malice. It was the commonest error in his profession and,
16
he was coming to understand, in most others: the map believed over the
ground, the summary believed over the instrument, the sentence "it was taken
care of" believed over the empty page where the taking care of it would have
to be written.
He did not say any of that to Ed. He poured the coffee out and made fresh,
and they drank it watching the heron, and the matter rested where he had put
it, in an envelope, in the mail, in the record — begun, correctly, and slow.
For three weeks, nothing came. Nothing came in the specific, accumulating
manner of an institution deciding that silence is a position. No reply to the
letter. No corrected statement. No book and page. The green return receipt
came back signed by someone at the clubhouse office, and Tom filed it
behind the letter copy and noted the date on the folder in pencil, and went on
with his October. He re-set a fence line at the meadow's corner that did not
need re-setting. He changed the truck's oil and its plugs and rotated its tires in
an order of his own devising. He and Ed took the canoe out twice, in the
mornings when the lake was glass and the bass were philosophical. He slept
the sleep of a man who has done what the record asked of him and can prove
it.
On a Friday, in the third week, an envelope from the association arrived in
the Point Road boxes, one for each of the six lots, identical but for the name.
Tom's was addressed to him at Lot 6, and it was not a reply to his letter, and
it did not mention his letter. It was a revised statement. The retroactive dues
stood exactly as announced: two thousand one hundred and fifty dollars, now
presented as a balance, with a due date, in the typography of an obligation.
And beneath it, added in the revision like a signature flourish, there was a
new line: RECORDS REVIEW FEE — $75.00. Somewhere in the clubhouse