HOA Karen Tried To Tow My Truck And Force My Land Into Her HOA—Until A Retired Surveyor Pointed Me Toward A Boundary Map She Never Expected Me To Find

Chapter 25

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

need to unsay. Coverage, the letter observed, extended to the acts of the

association's officers undertaken within the association's authority. The

carrier noted the pending chancery action. It noted the certified index. It

noted — Tom could hear the adjuster's pen slowing down for this part — the

67

owner's written objection, delivered to the association before the tow,

contesting the very jurisdiction under which the tow was ordered. And it

questioned, without yet denying, whether a tow ordered on land outside the

association's jurisdiction, over the written objection of the land's owner, fell

within the coverage at all. The carrier reserved its rights. It would continue to

monitor. It wished everyone a pleasant autumn.

Molly's note, in the margin, in pencil: They are deciding whether Carol was

the association when she did it, or just a neighbor with a tow truck's phone

number. If the second, the association's defense costs are about to get very

lonely.

Tom read the letter twice. He was not a man who enjoyed other people's

narrowing straits, but he permitted himself, reading it, the surveyor's

satisfaction of a traverse closing: every leg of the season's measurement, run

independently — the deed room, the bankruptcy court, the chancellor, the

bank, and now the carrier — arriving at the same corner from a different

direction. The point was being fixed. That is what a surveyor calls it when

the lines agree: not victory. A fix.

Greg Nolan came to his porch on the Friday of that week, in the evening, in

the blue hour, without Carol's knowledge — that much was plain from the

way he parked below the drive and walked up the gravel like a man

approaching his own fence line from the wrong side — and without quite

asking permission of himself, which was plainer still. Greg was the

association's treasurer, its numbers man, recruited to the board years ago for

the unglamorous virtue of being unable to let a column fail to add. He had a

banker's forearms and a church treasurer's conscience, and he stood on Tom's

porch with his hands in his jacket pockets and looked at the water for a while

before he looked at Tom.

68

"I'm not here for the board," he said.

"I can see that, Greg."

"I don't know whose behalf I'm here on. That's part of the — " He stopped.

"You want the position? I'll give you the position. It's what I'm for, positions.

The dues claim is dead. The injunction killed it and the title commitment

buried it. The vote is poisoned — six lots that aren't members made the

marina, and I cannot certify that roll to a bank, Tom, I cannot put my name

under it, and I've told exactly one person that, and it's you, just now. The loan

is suspended until the paper's true. And the carrier is circling the tow like it's

deciding whether we were ever — " he caught himself, and finished more

quietly " — whether the association was ever in the room when it happened."

Tom said nothing. A man unburdening himself is a measurement in progress;

you do not interrupt the crew.

"And that's not the worst of it. The worst of it is why I'm on your porch

instead of in my own kitchen minding my own ledger." Greg took his hands

out of his pockets and put them on the porch rail, and held on to it the way a

man holds a rail in weather. "I found an email. Assembling the claim file —

the carrier wanted everything, so I pulled everything, back to the manager

before last. Twenty twenty-two. The association's own manager, the

professional one, the firm — he wrote to Carol and to the board chair that

year. About the Phase Three file. He said he'd been asked to rely on it for a

closing disclosure and he'd gone looking for the recorded instrument and he

couldn't find it, because — " Greg looked out at the point, at the six lots'

lights, " — because, and this is his sentence, Tom, I've read it forty times,

'the Phase Three file has always been a draft in search of a recording,' and he

advised against relying on it until it was cured. Advised. In writing. To the

president."

69

"She was warned," Tom said.

"She was warned by our own man, for this exact reason, three years before

she sent a tow truck onto your land." Greg's voice did not rise. It did

something worse; it steadied. "Half the board believes she knew the paper

was thin. I am not half the board, Tom. I am the whole treasurer. I have not

shown that email to Carol. I don't know why I haven't. Loyalty, maybe.

Cowardice with a better tailor. I showed it to my wife and she said, show it to

Tom Archer, he'll know what a man does with a thing like that. So." He

turned from the rail. "What does a man do with a thing like that? What is a

treasurer supposed to do with a thing like that?"

Tom considered the question with the seriousness it had walked up his

driveway to earn. Below the porch the dark was coming down over the point

the way it always did, lot by lot, neighborly, indifferent, and the lake beyond

was going the color of slate, and somewhere in the middle distance a screen

door closed, once, on somebody's ordinary evening.

"The same thing a surveyor does with a bad closure," Tom said. "Greg, when

a traverse doesn't close — when the lines come back to the start and the start

isn't where the notes say it is — you don't average the error away and you

News in the same category

HOA Karen Tried To Tow My Truck And Force My Land Into Her HOA—Until A Retired Surveyor Pointed Me Toward A Boundary Map She Never Expected Me To Find

45 Part