supplemental declaration and the written consent of the owner, the
association's jurisdiction over Lot 6 is not defective, it is nonexistent, and
every act taken under it must be unwound.
"Fourteen days," Molly said, sealing it. "They'll take twelve to decide they're
angry and two to hire a lawyer to say it. What they answer will tell us which
kind of wrong Carol Hensley is. There's the kind that backs up when the
paper comes out. And there's the other kind."
The answer came in four days.
It came on the association attorney's letterhead — a firm in the county seat,
two names and a row of initials — and it was one page long, and Tom read it
standing at the mailbox with the rest of the mail under his arm, the way a
man reads weather. The board, the letter said, respectfully disagreed with Mr.
34
Archer's characterization of the Phase Three annexation. The annexation of
Phase Three was effected by the developer prior to the developer's cessation
of operations and is reflected in the association's records. A copy of the
supplemental declaration was enclosed for his convenience. The association
considered the dues and fines validly assessed and the tow a lawful exercise
of its enforcement remedies. The association trusted the matter could be
resolved amicably.
Effected by the developer. Prior to the developer's cessation of operations.
Tom stood in the sun at the end of his driveway — his driveway, from which
his truck had been taken for being unregistered in the eyes of a clipboard —
and he turned the enclosure over in his hands. A supplemental declaration for
Phase Three. Three pages. A signature block for the developer's company,
signed in a hand he did not know. A notary's block, completed. And at the
foot of the last page, where the register's office does its work, the recording
stamp: the instrument's number, the book and page — Book 412, Page 88 —
and the date, stamped in the register's ink: March, 2009.
March of 2009. The developer bankrupt in 2009, the office half empty, the
principals gone to Florida and to judgment — and in March of that year, on
the association's account, the developer had tidied the Point into the
association with a stroke, and the stroke had slept in the association's records
for sixteen years, and nobody at the courthouse had ever mentioned it,
because — Tom had held the register's index for Phase Three in his own
hands, at his purchase three years ago, and knew its thinness — the county
had never heard of it.
He took it inside. He put it on the desk under the lamp. He got out the
certified copy of his own deed, from the same office, and laid the two stamps
side by side, his deed's and the enclosure's, the way a man lays two calls of
35
the same line side by side to see which one lies.
The register's office had used, as long as Tom had been reading its stamps —
forty years, back to hand-set wheels and ink that came in bottles — a
condensed gothic typeface for its recording stamps: narrow, upright letters,
close-set, the numerals lean as fence posts. In 2005 the office had changed its
stamp machine, and Tom remembered the change the way other men
remember a courthouse fire: the new stamp lettered in the same gothic, but
with the date wheels in a different order and the county's name above the line
instead of below it. Every instrument recorded in Elk Shoals County since
2005 bore the new stamp. His own deed bore it.
The stamp on the supplemental declaration was in the old typeface. The
retired one. The face the register's office had put away in 2005 — the wide
letters, the date in the old order, the county's name riding below like a
signature — struck, so it claimed, in March of 2009, four years after the
machine that made it had ceased to exist in that office, onto a document the
county's index had never carried, by a developer already in bankruptcy,
annexing six lots whose owners had never been asked.
Tom sat with it a long time. Outside, the evening was doing its ordinary work
on the lake; a boat came in somewhere down the Point, running lights, a
man's laugh carried over the water. The truck sat in the barn with its hurt
gearbox. The closing file sat in the open drawer, growing its second
profession. On the desk, under the lamp, lay the association's whole position,
printed and stamped, and it was false in the way a thing is false when
someone has made it rather than found it — false the way a moved pin is
false, a pin driven at night into ground it was never surveyed from, with the
ribbon tied on bright and new.
He picked up the telephone, and then he put it down again, because what he
36
had to tell her would keep until morning exactly as well as it had kept for
sixteen years. He held the page up to the lamp instead — held it up to the
light the way he had held a thousand pages up to courthouse windows,
looking for the watermark, the impression, the truth of the paper itself —
looking at a stamp from a machine that did not exist anymore, in a typeface
four years retired, on a declaration the county had never heard of, while
outside his window the dark came down on a road six households used to get
home, and the board that claimed those households met, that same evening,
three miles away, to plan a marina.