collected to be credited or refunded as the owners elected; the tellers took
twenty minutes, because in Heron Bay a count was a count, and the secretary
read the result aloud in the same voice she had read Article XII: two hundred
and three to nineteen. The second voided the marina assessment for the
miscount of the roll — an assessment carried by four votes on the strength of
six lots that had never been the association's to count could not stand, the
mover said, and if the board still wanted its marina it could come back and
ask a truthful roll for it, in daylight, with the renderings — and it carried by a
margin nobody bothered to make the tellers certify.
103
Between the second motion and the third there was a pause in which the
room did the thing rooms do when the formal business has outrun the script:
it talked, all at once, in the low register of people who have been handed
back a piece of their own history and are turning it over. Tom heard the
marina assessed and reassessed in a dozen conversations, heard the
gatehouse hours defended, heard a man he had known since the eighties
explain to his son-in-law that the lots had been billed in 2010 and that he,
personally, had paid the 2010 bill on a house he later sold, and that he would
like to know — he said it without heat, as a man inquires after a survey
marker he once set and can no longer find — he would like to know where
that money had gone, and into what account it had been posted, it having
been collected on air. The interim board would spend the winter answering
that question, and Tom did not envy them the answering, because he knew
the arithmetic: the money had gone where association money goes, into roads
and dredging and the fire contract, into the lake itself, spent honestly in the
service of a community by people who believed they were entitled to collect
it. There was no villain's pocket at the bottom of the sum. That was the part
nobody said aloud that night, and it was the part that made the restitution
motions pass the way they did, with the air of a neighborhood settling a bill it
had run up in its own name.
The recall was the third motion, and Carol did not wait for it. The tellers had
not finished — the slips were still coming up the aisles in the coffee can the
association had used for ballots since 1998 — when she stood, picked up the
gavel, and set it down in front of the vice president's chair, handle toward
him, the way a person surrenders a tool they expect to be used properly by
the next hands. She thanked the secretary, then, in the hearing of the whole
room, for reading Article XII in full and slowly, because, she said, it was the
first time in eleven years of chairing meetings under it that she had ever
104
actually heard it, and she thought the association might consider making a
practice of that. She took her folder and her coat from the back of the
president's chair and sat down in the second row, in a member's seat, before
the tally was announced. When it was announced — and it carried, plainly,
by a count the secretary read and Tom did not write down, because Carol had
already finished the matter herself — she received it the way she had
received the email's reading, upright, with her hands in her lap, looking at the
easel by the door, where the little white boats rode at their docks in a marina
that did not, any longer, have a roll to pay for it.
The tow settlement came last and came from the floor, which Molly Tran had
predicted in October it would, on the grounds that communities prefer to pay
their debts in public when the alternative is having them itemized by a
chancellor. It was adopted as the policy of the association, in a single motion,
without amendment: the three hundred and fifty dollars Tom had paid under
protest to recover his own truck from Hensley Recovery's yard was to be
repaid; the transmission was to be made whole on the shop's estimate, four
thousand six hundred dollars, without a second opinion; and his legal fees
were to be submitted to the carrier without opposition from the association,
the new board having concluded that a community which had towed a man's
truck on air could hardly haggle over the cost of his having pointed it out.
Tom stood, because his knees required it after three hours, and said that the
Point Road owners accepted, and that the stipulation his counsel had drafted
would be circulated within the week, and he sat down again before the
applause could decide what it was for.
The stipulation took Molly Tran four days, and it was a surveyor's document
as much as a lawyer's, which Tom chose to believe was why the chancellor
signed it the way he did. In it the association acknowledged, for itself and its
105
successors, the phase boundary of record: the six lots at the end of Point
Road lay outside the declaration, had never been annexed to it, and could be
brought within it only in the manner Article XII prescribed, by consents
executed and recorded. The withdrawal of the bills was recited. The
settlement of the tow was recited. And at Molly's insistence — she had said,