HOA Karen Tried To Tow My Truck And Force My Land Into Her HOA—Until A Retired Surveyor Pointed Me Toward A Boundary Map She Never Expected Me To Find

Chapter 4

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

the Point Road lots are regularized. Their dues will be brought current — one

year retroactive, for bookkeeping neatness, at the standard rate. That comes

to two thousand one hundred and fifty dollars per lot." She said the number

the way she said all numbers, like a destination. "It's only fair. They've had

the benefit of the community for years. Now they'll share the costs, like the

9

rest of us. And when we vote the marina assessment this fall — which will

require, under our documents, a two-thirds vote of the full membership —

the Point Road lots will take their place in the count, as they should."

There was applause of the measured, subdivision kind, and Ed Kowalski

wrote something in his notebook with unnecessary force, and Tom sat in the

guest chair at the back of the room with his hands folded and felt the whole

presentation settle over him like a survey line drawn by a man who has never

walked the ground — confident, straight, and passing, in its confidence,

directly through his house.

He had not come intending to speak. In eleven years of annual meetings he

had never spoken; the guest chairs were for listening, and he had a surveyor's

respect for the difference between the row you sit in and the business on the

floor. But there are questions that are not really questions, and a man who

has spent his life making sure the paper matches the ground learns to hear

them the way a piano tuner hears a false note in another room. When Carol

opened the floor — "Questions, before we move to the treasurer's report" —

Tom stood up in the back, in the unhurried way he did everything, and the

room turned the small, polite quarter-turn of a room accommodating a guest.

"Mrs. Hensley," he said. "One question, on the Phase Three matter. The

original Declaration — the 1987 document — has an Article Twelve in it. It

says an occupied lot can be annexed to this association only with the lot

owner's written consent. I've lived on Lot Six for eleven years, and I don't

recall consenting, and I don't recall being asked. So I'd like to know: was a

supplemental declaration for Phase Three ever recorded at the courthouse —

and if the annexation rests on consent, whose consent is on file?"

He said it mildly. He said it the way he would have said it to a title examiner

across a counter, as a question about the record, with no more heat in it than

10

a request for a book and page number. The room was quiet in the new way

rooms are quiet when a pleasant evening has encountered an unexpected fact.

Carol Hensley smiled the smile of a woman who has closed a thousand loans

across a desk from a thousand hesitations, and she answered without

consulting a single paper, which Tom noticed, and filed.

"The annexation was completed by the developer, Mr. Archer, before the —

before the transition. All of that was handled at the development level." She

let the smile widen by the width of one reassurance. "The office will be

happy to provide the paperwork to anyone who needs it."

"Book and page," Tom said, "would do it."

"The office will provide it," she said, pleasantly, and turned — not rudely,

which was almost worse; smoothly, the way a river turns around a stone it

has no intention of arguing with — to the next raised hand, which belonged

to a woman from Phase Two who wanted to know whether the new marina

slips would be assigned by lottery. Ed Kowalski looked down at his

notebook, where he had written, in block capitals, the words BOOK AND

PAGE, and underlined them twice, and then, after a moment's thought,

written beneath them: SHE DIDN'T SAY IT.

The treasurer's report was read. The fall vote was scheduled and announced:

the marina assessment, two-thirds of the full membership required, the

membership to include, for the first time in the association's history, the six

lots at the end of Point Road. The meeting adjourned into coffee and

comment, and people were kind to Tom in the parking lot in the way of

people who have enjoyed a small disturbance at a distance and bear its author

no ill will for providing it. He drove home under a sky gone to stars, the

F-250's headlights yellow and strong in the dark, the road narrowing, the lake

opening, and his house lit the way he had left it, and none of it felt different,

11

which he understood, even then, was the trick trouble plays on the first

evening: it arrives dressed as a meeting.

He made tea he did not drink and sat down at the desk in the back room,

where the plat cabinet stood against the wall with its wide shallow drawers,

and opened the file that every surveyor keeps and no homeowner should ever

need: his own closing file, eleven years old, its folder gone soft at the

corners. He opened it now with the particular feeling of a man going down

into a cellar he himself had stocked.

The owner's title policy was on top, because he had put it on top, eleven

years ago, in the order of a closing he had essentially conducted himself

despite the presence of professionals — the agent had joked about it, the

attorney had not. He turned past the jacket, past the endorsement page, to

Schedule B, which is the part of a title policy where the truth lives: the

exceptions, the matters the land is subject to, listed one by one in the

News in the same category

HOA Karen Tried To Tow My Truck And Force My Land Into Her HOA—Until A Retired Surveyor Pointed Me Toward A Boundary Map She Never Expected Me To Find

45 Part