He went to the courthouse on a Tuesday, early, because the deed room was a
place that rewarded the early. By nine the abstractors would be at the long
tables with their laptops and their rolling carts, but at eight-fifteen the room
belonged to the county and to the smell of it, which was the smell of Tom
Archer's whole working life: old paper and floor wax, the iron tang of the
plat cabinets, coffee gone serious in a pot that had been on since the building
opened. He had pulled title in that room when the indexes were still all in
books, great canvas-bound ledgers chained to their stands like Bibles in a
church that expected thieves. He had pulled title in it when the computers
came, and had watched the older clerks regard the screens the way farmers
regard weather radar, with respect and a settled disbelief. He knew which
drawer stuck, and he knew the sound the map drawers made, a long metallic
sigh, like something deciding to tell the truth slowly.
Marjorie Tate was on the counter. She had been a deputy clerk when he was
still running a crew, and she had recorded plats he had drawn and deeds he
had only witnessed the edges of, and there was between them the ease of two
people who have spent forty years being accurate in the same building. She
37
looked up from her screen and took in the folder under his arm, which was
the board's folder, or rather the folder Molly Tran had made of the board's
papers, tabbed and flagged in a litigator's colors.
"Business or pleasure, Tom?"
"Business," he said. "The kind that needs a seal on it."
He told her what he wanted, and he told it in the order a title search wants to
be told, because a search requested badly gets answered badly and he had not
come for a bad answer. He wanted a certified search of the records of the
county for any supplemental declaration, amendment, or annexation
instrument touching Heron Bay Estates, Phase Three, or the Point Road lots,
for the years 2008 through 2010. He wanted the grantor and grantee indexes
run under the developer's name, Heron Bay Development Corporation, both
directions, grantor out and grantee in, for the same years. He wanted the plat
index checked. And he wanted the instrument the association claimed to hold
— Book 412, Page 88, recorded, they said, in March of 2009 — pulled by its
book and page and read for what it was.
Marjorie wrote it down on a request slip in her small, square hand. "You
want the office to run it, or you want to stand there and watch me run it?"
"Both," Tom said. "Run it yourself, the way the office runs it. Then let me
run it my way, with you watching, the way you'd watch a man sight down his
own line. If the two searches agree, that's a fact. If they don't, that's a better
fact."
She considered him a moment, and something in her face acknowledged the
courtesy of the thing, because what he had asked for, under the plain words,
was a witness: a clerk who had stood beside the man while he found nothing,
in every place nothing could hide, was a story that could be told in a
38
courtroom without a single raised voice.
"Give me the morning," she said. "And give me that copy of theirs, so I know
what I'm not finding."
He handed over the board's supplemental declaration, or what the board
called its supplemental declaration: three pages, the third bearing the lines for
the developer's signature over a notary's block, and in the upper right corner
of the first page the recording stamp, blue-black and confident:
RECORDED, with the book and page filled in by hand, 412 and 88, and the
date, March of 2009, and the recorder's name in the small type beneath. It
was the stamp he had been looking at, on and off, for weeks, the way a man
looks at a survey marker that reads right and sits wrong. The typeface of it.
He had not let himself think about the typeface yet. A man who starts with
the small wrongness may never get to the large one, and the large one was
first: the thing was not in the books. If it was in the books, the typeface was a
footnote. If it was not, the typeface would keep.
The office ran its search first. Marjorie went to the computer because the
county's records for those years lived in both countries, paper and pixel, and
she ran the developer's name through the grantor index with the patience of a
woman defusing something. Heron Bay Development Corporation, grantor,
2008. A deed of trust. A partial release. Heron Bay Development
Corporation, grantor, 2009. A warranty deed to a lot buyer in Phase Two. A
deed of trust to the bank that had believed in the development longest. A
corrective deed, a lot-line adjustment, a power of attorney. 2010: nothing,
because by 2010 there was nothing left of the corporation to give or take.
The grantee index, the same years, the corporation receiving: releases,
satisfactions, a trustee's deed that ended things. She ran the plat index. She
ran the miscellaneous index where amendments and declarations go when the
39
computer cannot decide what they are, and where, in a county that recorded
carefully, they were also cross-indexed under the subdivision's name. She ran
Heron Bay Estates itself as a search term, all phases, all years, and read him