people's celebrations, for over a decade. He unfolded; she spaced. She had
always been particular about the aisle — a boat's width, she used to say —
and he set the rows to her spacing without being asked, and she, without
comment, moved the head table the six inches toward the window that he had
always maintained gave the speakers the light and she had always maintained
did not matter. The water carafe went where it went. The microphone was
tested — his voice, then hers, each saying the room's name into it like a
password: testing, Heron Bay, testing. The spare chairs went along the back
wall in their stack, for the latecomers, for the standers, for the people who
90
would decide at the door whether they were members of this. When the room
was done they stood a moment in the satisfaction that has nothing to do with
the purpose of a room and everything to do with its readiness, and neither of
them reached for a speech. The folder stayed closed on the head table. The
affidavit stayed home in his. Between those two closed folders the chairs
stood in their rows like a plat waiting for its legend.
At the door she stopped with her hand on the frame, and asked him, without
strategy — he could hear the absence of it, the plainness where the campaign
used to be — "Do you hate the marina, Tom? Actually. Not the counting of
it. The thing itself."
"I like marinas," he said. "I keep a boat in this one. I've kept one there since
before there was a waitlist. If it grows, I'll walk farther to my slip and
complain about the walk like everybody else."
"Do you hate me, then?" she asked. "It would simplify the minutes."
He considered the question with the seriousness it had been asked in. "I hate
a bad record, Carol," he said. "You're just the first president who filed one in
my driveway."
She laughed — once, surprised out of her, the real article, the boat-ramp
laugh that had christened half the fleet — and shook her head, and it was
almost a conversation, and then it wasn't, quite, and was something older and
plainer instead. She pulled the door to behind them and tested it, the way he
would have. The lock took. The lights in the windows went off one bank at a
time as they walked out into the November dark, and the room stood ready
behind them in its rows, and the two of them stood a moment longer in the
doorway of it like surveyors at either end of a line that tomorrow, at last,
would finally be run in public.
91
The clubhouse had been built for a smaller Heron Bay, and on the night of
the special meeting it held the whole of the larger one, which is to say it held
more people than it had chairs. They stood along the back wall in their coats,
because November had come in wet off the lake and the room's heat,
generated by two hundred bodies and a radiator that had never once in thirty
years been correctly bled, made the windows run. Tom Archer sat where he
had sat at every meeting since the spring — third row, aisle seat, the folder
on his knees — and he watched the room assemble itself the way he had
watched it assemble all year, except that tonight the assembly had a different
geometry. The Point Road owners had come in together and taken the row of
chairs under the windows, all six households in a line: the Whitakers, Mrs.
Fournier with her cane hooked over the chair back, the two Petrakis brothers,
and Tom at the end nearest the aisle, so that the six lots that had never joined
the association sat along the glass like a delegation from a small country that
had been summoned to explain itself and had decided, politely, to be
explained to instead.
By the door, on the easel where they had stood since March, were the marina
renderings. Nobody had taken them down. Tom had remarked on this to Ed
Kowalski in the parking lot — the renderings still up, the little white boats
still riding at their little white docks under a sky the color of a real-estate
brochure — and Ed had shrugged and said that nobody had had the heart,
and nobody had had the orders, which between them accounted for most of
what did not get done in Heron Bay. The renderings faced the room at a
slight angle, so that from Tom's seat the marina appeared to be leaning into
the meeting, listening.
The association's attorney sat at the officers' table with his folder closed in
front of him and his hands folded on top of it, and Tom, who had spent the
92
autumn across various rooms from Mr. Finch, had learned to read the man
the way he read a plat: by the small things. In September Finch had kept his
folder open and a pen uncapped. In October he had brought a second folder.
Tonight the folder was closed, the pen was nowhere, and his tie had been
loosened by exactly the amount a man loosens it when he has stopped
expecting to be believed and has settled for being accurate. He looked, Tom
thought, like the only officer in his own camp who had read the whole file,
which was unfair to exactly one other person in the room, and that person
was the treasurer, and Greg Nolan was sitting very still with a single sheet of