The chancellor wrote something down. He wrote it slowly, the way a man
writes a thing he intends to read again later and be sure of. "Believed," he
said. "By whom?"
"By the association, Your Honor."
"And the recording information on the association's copy — the book and
page in the stamp — what instrument occupies that book and page in the
deed room?"
Counsel consulted his own binder then, which was the first time all morning
he had needed to, and Tom, watching from the second row, felt no triumph in
it at all, only a kind of sorrowing recognition, the way you feel when a man
you are measuring against discovers his own error in the field, in front of
witnesses, with the chain still in his hands.
"The instrument at that book and page," counsel said at last, "is a deed of
trust. In another matter."
56
"A deed of trust," the chancellor said. "Another man's deed of trust."
"Yes, Your Honor."
"Then the stamp on the association's copy records a document that is not the
document." The chancellor set down his pen. "I want to be careful here,
because the association's position, as I understand it, is that it believed its
paper. Belief is a fine thing in a church. In a deed room it is a rumor. Ms.
Tran."
Molly stood, and if she was nervous it did not survive the journey from her
shoulders to her voice. She did not give a speech. She gave the court a
survey, point by point, each one tied to the next by something a man could
check. The certified index of the grantor-grantee records, she said, covering
the developer, the association, and every instrument touching Phase Three
from the original declaration forward: no supplemental declaration appeared,
because none had ever been recorded. The original declaration's own Article
XII, which the association did not dispute, required annexation by recorded
supplemental declaration, and by no other means. The developer's
bankruptcy file, opened in the year after the last Point Road lot was sold,
contained the annexation among its schedules of unfinished business, in
draft, unsigned, bearing a clerk's marginal note in a dead hand: not executed;
annexation not completed. And the association's stamped copy — she held it
up then, in its plastic sleeve, like a fish that had not survived the trip — was
the developer's own file copy, stamped at the developer's office, shelved
wrong in 2010 among the recorded instruments by a manager long since
gone, and believed in ever since, the way a wrong corner gets believed in: by
being used.
"The association believed in it so completely," Molly said, "that this spring it
towed my client's truck off his own land for the crime of owing dues to an
57
association he has never belonged to. It believed in it so completely that it
has billed six households, on Point Road, for years, for membership that
exists nowhere in the public record of this county. We are not asking the
court to punish a belief, Your Honor. We are asking the court to say what the
record says, and to keep the association's hands off my client and his
neighbors while the court finishes saying it."
The association's counsel rose once more, because there was one more leg of
the traverse to run and he was paid to run it. Fifteen years, he said. Fifteen
years in which the Point Road households had driven the association's roads,
used the marina, received the association's services without protest. If the
annexation was a nullity, it was a nullity the plaintiffs had lived inside
comfortably for a decade and a half, and equity, he suggested, had something
to say about a man who accepted the benefits of a community and disputed
the burdens only when the bill grew teeth.
The chancellor let him finish. "Counsel, the roads those families drive —
how do they reach them?"
"By — the roads are association roads, Your Honor, maintained by — "
"The plat, counsel. I have read the plat. The lots on Point Road reach the
county road over an easement recorded with their deeds, granted before this
association existed. A man who drives home over his own easement is not
accepting a benefit. He is going home." He turned a page of his notes, though
Tom suspected the page was blank. "Does the association contend that use of
a recorded easement converts it, over time, into a covenant of membership?
Because if it does, I will need the authority for that proposition, and I will
need it by Friday, and I suspect — " the smallest pause " — we will both still
be waiting for it at Christmas."
58
Counsel sat down with the air of a man setting down a chain he has
discovered is not attached to anything.
The chancellor asked her two questions — one about the easement, which
she answered from the plat, and one about the tow, which she answered from
Ed's film, already lodged with the clerk — and then he leaned back and
looked at the ceiling for a moment, at the water stain there in the shape of no
state anyone could name, and issued the injunction from the bench in the
plain terms of a man who has found the bottom of a matter and intends to
stand on it.
Pending final judgment, the association would not enforce against the Point
Road lots. It would not tow. It would not fine. It would not restrict,
condition, or interfere with their recorded easement access to Point Road or
the county road beyond it. The bills — the dues, the fines, the tow charges,